SGM Herbert A. Friedman (Ret.)
Lieutenant Colonel William J. Jacobs
7th PSYOP Battalion
In the I Corps Tactical Zone, the 7th PSYOP Battalion of the 4th PSYOP Group was formed in Nha Trang from the 6th Bn's 244th PSYOP Company. It was officially constituted 7 November 1967 in the Regular Army as the 7th Psychological Operations Battalion. It was activated 1 December 1967. Since elements of the 244th PSYOP Company were already in Danang, the 7th PSYOP Battalion absorbed the unit and was headquartered there. It departed Vietnam on 21 December 1971 and was inactivated at Fort Lewis, Washington.
According to the Operations Report Lessons Learned Headquarters 7th Psychological Operations Battalion period ending 31 January, 1968 dated 6 February 1968, the number of leaflets printed during the last quarter of 1967 was 59 million. In addition the battalion took credit for 61 ralliers; Newsletter/Newspapers: 32,000; Ground Loudspeaker Broadcasts: 2,284 hours and 5 minutes; Motion Picture showings: 423 hours and 55 minutes; Movies shown: 699; Leaflets printed: 59,944,800; Leaflets printed Chieu Hoi: 14,977,610; Posters printed: 646,350; Total impressions: 13,850,249; New leaflets: 168; Sorties: 1222; Leaflets dropped: 620,140,500; Airborne Loudspeaker Broadcasts: 863 hours and 45 minutes and Leaflets shipped: 10,121,900.
Two additional battalion records were set during the quarter as they produced a total of 2 million leaflets in one day and a total of 7,250,500 leaflets in one week.
A 1968 U.S. Army 4th PSYOP Group booklet for newly arriving members says:
Winning the hearts and minds of the people of I Corps is one responsibility of the 7th PSYOP Battalion in Da Nang. Working closely with the Marine Corps, the battalion also provides PSYOP support for all operations in the northernmost corps. This support comes in the form of leaflet and broadcast messages and field teams. During the 1968 Tet Offensive, the battalion provided teams to such areas as Hue and Khe Sanh to give assistance to Allied units in battle scarred areas. The battalion headquarters is located on the ARVN 10th Political Warfare (POLWAR) Battalion compound. Enlisted men of the unit live in the Palace Hotel while Officers reside in the Hotel Than Nhat. During off-duty time, the men of the battalion relax at one of the many beaches located in the Da Nang area. Although the city itself is off limits to American military personnel, many recreational facilities are provided within a short distance of the battalion compound.
Although we dont know what specific propaganda leaflets were dropped on the Communist forces besieging the Marines as Khe Sanh, we do know that C-47 aircraft from Flight A of the 9th Air Commando Squadron, 14th Air Commando Wing, dropped a total of 31,000,000 leaflets in adverse weather on the enemy and the units Commander was awarded an Army Commendation Medal for deterring enemy forces from conducting a massive ground assault on the Khe Sahn position.
Speaking of the Air Commando squadrons, the 5th Air Commando Squadron was mentioned prominently in the 16 July 1966 issue of the Chicago Tribune:
The squadron is based in Nha Trang, but also operates out of Da Nang in the north, Pleiku in the central highlands and Bien Hoa near Saigon. Since it arrived in November 1965, its planes, armed only with leaflets and tape recordings have been hit 51 times. It has not lost any, but two of its flyers have been wounded.
During its first month in Vietnam, the squadron flew 74 paper and shout sorties. Since then the missions have built up each month. In 1,173 sorties in June 1966 it dropped 130 million leaflets and spent 575 hours in loudspeaker appeals. The squadron uses four C-47 two-engine cargo planes and 16 of the new U-10 light aircraft that can take off and land in 300 feet.
The 5th squadron can claim part of the credit for the increasing number of Communists giving up the fight. Some of these carry surrender leaflets. The number surrendering has risen to 2,300 a month.
Captain Anthony Mottle was a Detachment Commander in the 7th PSYOP Battalion based in
in 1970. When asked about his duties he said: Da Nang
The mission of the unit was to support the various units in I CORPS. We had a propaganda section in Da Nang that produced leaflets for units such as the 1st Marine Division, the 2nd Brigade of the 101st Airborne Division at Phu Bai, The 23rd (Americal) Infantry Division at Chu Lai and the 1st Brigade of the 5th Mechanized Infantry Division. We had a Vietnamese psychologist working for us in the propaganda section. We usually assigned two-man teams to the supported units that went out with the maneuver forces to broadcast to the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army troops. We had helicopters at our disposal at the various units to broadcast to the enemy and disseminate leaflets. We also participated in Medical Civic Action Programs.
Specialist 5th Class Pasquale Vallese who was in
Vietnamfrom November 1968 to November 1969 as part of the Army 7th PSYOP Battalion attached to the 3rd Marine Division remarked: U.S.
I was assigned to B company, and I was sent to Dong Ha, stationed with the 3rd Marines at their base camp. Our unit was the Marines G2/G5 staff, so we did have a sort of free hand in our comings and goings. We did the field broadcasting with Kit Carson Scouts and ARVN interpreters throughout northern I Corps. I found out early that the Marines like to use the PSYOP message to draw fire to locate the
Regulars so I revised our field speaker system. My first revision was to get 50 yards of speaker cable, do some splicing and soldering and cut the speaker rack down to two horns from four. That made it a little safer to broadcast. We are talking 1968 thru 1969. I Corps had just lost Khe Sanh and NVA and VC were a tough audience to convince to Chieu Hoi. However, We did have some walk right up to us with their safe conduct passes. North Vietnam
Since we are talking about the 7th PSYOP Battalion, the Marines and Khe Sanh, this seems a nice place for this leaflet. If you want to piss off a Marine, tell him how the Army and Air Force saved the Leathernecks during the 1968 seventy-seven day siege of Khe Sanh. Marines will tell you that they were doing just fine and had the enemy right where they wanted them. Ask the Army and you will hear that the Marines were getting the Hell kicked out of them by the NVA. During the ferocious battle for Khe Sanh, the 7th PSYOP Battalion prepared a leaflet for the North Vietnamese forces taking part in the attack. The front of the leaflet depicts a map of Khe Sanh and a Huey helicopter and F4 Phantom jet attacking the forces encircling the Marine base. Curiously, there is no mention of the Marines. The text beneath the picture is:
The North Vietnamese will fail in their attempts to seize Quang Tri and Thua Thien Provinces. The Government of Vietnam and Allied firepower is defending every part of the South. You cannot survive if your invasion continues. You will be destroyed at Khe Sanh.
To the Men who Attack Khe Sanh
The march to Khe Sanh was a long and dangerous one. Many of your comrades who have come over to us speak of the misery you faced before you reached the desolate battlefield. Since arriving you have seen nothing but suffering and death. You have seen the tremendous B-52 strikes with bombs which will soon find you as they have found your comrades. From the artillery that has poured on you all day and night do you now realize how strong the Army of Vietnam and the Allied forces are? Now look at the valley to which you have been sent to die. You are surrounded instead of us. You are in the kill zone. To stay here means suffering, death and ultimate failure in a place far from your dear family.
If you want to get safely back to your family, leave now or rally to the National Government of Vietnam cause. Otherwise, Khe Sanh will be your useless grave.
The Units awards and decorations include the Meritorious Unit Commendation (Army) for
1967-1968, Navy Unit Commendation for Vietnam 1967-1968, Republic of Vietnam Cross of Gallantry with Palm for Vietnam Vietnam1971, and Republicof Vietnam Civil Action Honor Medal, First Class for 1967-1970. Like the Vietnam , the 7th PSYOP Battalion was eventually reborn. It was redesignated 16 June 1996 as Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 11th Psychological Operations Battalion, and activated at Phoenix Washington, D.C.
One of the more interesting PSYOP campaigns supported by the 7th PSYOP Battalion was Operation Searchlight. It was launched in Military Region I and was designed to influence enemy soldiers to defect during the Tet truce period of 19-29 January 1971. Giant searchlights would be aimed at the sky and the enemy urged to follow the beam to the searchlight where they could safely surrender. During an earlier test of the searchlight operation on 1 January, eleven Viet Cong defected. In the major operation the U.S. 101st Airborne Division used six lights, the 2nd Vietnamese Army Division, the U.S. 1st Marine Division and the U.S. 23rd Infantry Division all used five lights each. The operation was not a great success, and estimates of from zero to seven to thirty-seven defectors were rumored. The above leaflet was prepared by the 7th PSYOP Battalion for Operation Searchlight. It depicts a pair of searchlights aimed skyward and the Chieu Hoi Symbol. The PSYOP theme was Rally to the light of freedom and start a new life with the Government of Vietnam. Two broadcast tapes were prepared and 6,000,000 leaflets, 500,000 handbills and 10,000 posters were printed and disseminated.
The text is:
THE LIGHT OF FREEDOM
During the cease fire period of Tan Hoi New Year, all
United States, , and other Allied bases will turn on their searchlight at night. The searchlight will help you to find freedom. Move toward the direction of light, hide your weapon and wait until the daylight to rally. When getting close to the Government of Vietnam or Allied units, shout aloud CHIEU HOI. You will be welcomes and receive good treatment. Guide the Government of Vietnam or Allied forces to recover your weapon for a reward. Vietnam
MOVE TO THE SEARCHLIGHT
DO NOT LET YOURSELF GET KILLED IN THE DARK
It is interesting to note that in the 1950s the British has successfully conquered a Communist insurrection in
Malaya. American propagandists studied the British techniques carefully. Note that British Leaflet 3211/HPWS/18 was printed about 1954 and depicts three guerillas discussing a searchlight in the distance. It is clear that the Americans copied the concept of the searchlight leaflet 16 years later. The text on the back is:
SEARCH LIGHT LEADS YOU TO THE ROAD OF ESCAPE
Look for the bright ray of the searchlight in the night sky. The searchlight is shining from the road.
If you want to escape from the forest to start a bright new life then run in the direction of the light to reach the road. The road will take you to a brand new happy and peaceful living environment.
Before you reach the road, please hide your weapons and ammunition. Then run to the road, raise both your hands high above your head and try to stop the first car that passes by.
All military drivers have been ordered to help you, and at the same time, civilians that assist you will receive a cash award.
If you stay in the jungle you will definitely be either shot dead ravaged by disease and hunger. A lot of people have escaped from the jungle and saved their own lives. Dont you want to save your life? Sacrificing yourself for an unnecessary and losing battle is a stupid thing to do.
You will definitely not be abused and you will immediately receive good food and medical treatment.
Come and join the side where your friends have already begun a new life.
8th PSYOP Battalion
In II Corps, the 8th PSYOP Battalion of the 4th PSYOP Group was formed in Nha Trang from the 6th PSYOP Bn's 245th PSYOP Company. Company B of the new 8th PSYOP Bn was formed from a small detachment of the 245th Company. Later, in 1968, all of the 8th PSYOP Battalion moved to Pleiku, where it served in close association with the 4th Infantry Division. It operated there until it departed
on 26 June 1971. Vietnam
According to the 8th PSYOP Battalion Operations Report for Quarterly Period Ending 31 January 1968, dated 6 February 1968, on 1 December 1967, the 8th PSYOP battalion was activated to replace the 245th PSYOP Company as the principle military PSYOP agency supporting operations within II Corps. The battalion consisted of 21 Officers and 68 enlisted.
Company A was located in Nha Trang and operated with C Flight, 9th Air Commandos Squadron, to provide PSYOP support to coastal provinces.
Company B was established in Pleiku to work with B Flight, 9th Air Commandos Squadron, on supporting the highland provinces.
8th Battalion maintained a total of 5 loudspeaker (HB) teams and 5 audio-visual (HE) teams). One HE team was attached to a province advisor team. this arrangement added flexibility which enabled the audio-visual team to support US tactical units, special cordon and search operations and a variety of revolutionary development programs.
The 9th Air Commando Squadron flew a total of 884 missions disseminating 450,518,000 leaflets and providing 1,526 hours of loudspeaker broadcasts with 22 night missions flown by AC-47 aircraft.
During the 1968 TET Campaign in II Corps, the 8th PSYOP Battalion was provided with two UH-1D helicopters from the 17th Aviation Group in Nha Trang. In addition, the 173rd Airborne Brigade loaned 2 AEM-ABS-4 1000 watt loudspeaker systems which were then rigged in the helicopters. The helicopter loudspeaker missions began operations on 27 January 1968 rendering quick reaction aerial PSYOP support to Khanh Hoa, Bin Thuan and Phu Yen provinces. A total of 94 leaflet/loudspeaker sorties were flown broadcasting a total of 953 hours and 15 minutes of recordings and dropping 3,494,000 leaflets.
Initially a problem occurred rigging the 1000 watt loudspeaker system. An expedient method of rigging these loudspeaker units was developed by a field leader while supporting the 2nd Brigade, 1st Cavalry Division (Air Mobile). This device which was constructed of scrap metal provided the necessary means to employ the speakers in the UH-1D helicopters.
Making a recording for loudspeaker broadcast
PSYOP Radio Station outside Pleiku City
The 1968 Army publication states:
In May 1968, a field team from the 8th PSYOP Battalion, using powerful ground loudspeakers, coaxed 95 North Vietnamese soldiers from a battered village North of
. The scope of Group PSYOP support in Hue is boundless. In II Corps, an 8th PSYOP Battalion advisory team assists Vietnamese radio broadcasters in programming PSYOP messages to hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese civilians, NVA soldiers and Viet Cong. 8th PSYOP Battalion radio technicians man the Group's 50-thousand watt transmitter from its hilltop site outside Vietnam . In connection with the operation, PSYOP aircraft have dropped thousands of small transistor radios to Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army troops. All are pretuned to the station's frequency. The 8th PSYOP Battalion provides PSYOP support for all of II Corps. To provide adequate coverage in Pleiku City 's largest corps it became necessary to detach one of its companies from its headquarters in Nha Trang and station it permanently in Pleiku. The Nha Trang and Pleiku elements have printing and field team capabilities. The company at Pleiku also maintains a small Vietnam (PDC), which is an extension of the Group PDC system. PSYOP Development Center
Newspaper article of the April 68 VC attack on the 8th PSYOP Bn Radio Station
(Photo courtesy of Rick Hofmann)
In addition to other duties, the battalion was charged with operation of the Groups 50,000 watt AM radio station in Pleiku. The mission of the station was to broadcast to audiences in a large area in the northern provinces of South Vietnam. The radio station had it problems. It was in a very exposed position. It had a guard tower manned by its own staff, barbed wire, and fence posts around it. The station was an outpost, not located within a defensive perimeter of any unit. The station was made up of modular vans that were partially dug into the hilltop and sandbagged. Another problem they had was jamming from Radio
. The Americans had bought tens of thousands of radio receivers and placed them all over the country so people could listen to the broadcasts. Initially these had fixed frequency reception, but they were easily jammed. They later provided tunable radios, so that listeners could change stations as the Americans attempted to avoid the Communist jamming. Hanoi
The Viet Cong sent about 20 sappers against the radio station on 24 March 1968. They threw satchel charges into several of the sandbagged modules and destroyed the radio tower. 7th PSYOP Detachment Commander 1LT Michael Merkle was killed in the attack and the Viet Cong lost about a half dozen sappers. Radio
bragged about the attack the morning afterwards. A new tower was shipped to Vietnam from the 7th PSYOP Group in Okinawa, all modules replaced, and the radio station was back on the air and the system fully functional in exactly ten days. Hanoi
In the Delta city of Can Tho, a 10th PSYOP Battalion advisory team assisted in the operation of the first television station for the heavily populated Mekong Delta.
Former Infantry Captain William W. Forgey mentions the attack:
The tower had been blown down by satchel charges. I do not remember if there was a mortar shelling by the enemy, but the attack was swift, concentrated, and over in a short matter of time.
Even with several 50 caliber machine guns that exposed position was untenable. The skill and courage of the crew that not only repaired this station, got it back on the air within 10 days, but also continued to man it from the edge of civilization (as we knew it) was astonishing. It was basically raw courage that kept that station going.
This attack is discussed in more depth in the Veritas, Journal of the Army Special Operations History, Volume 2, Number 3, 2006. Author Robert W. Jones Jr. says in part:
The radio station was essentially an outpost it was not inside any units defensive perimeter. As such, the small compound was very vulnerable to attack What distinguished the compound from the other American facilities in Pleiku was the 250-foot radio antenna. It quickly became a Viet Cong rocket and mortar aiming post and rounds were received almost daily. It was guarded by a Vietnamese Army squad. The 23rd ARVN Division was responsible for outer perimeter security in Pleiku.
The article discusses the attack much as we have already done above, and goes on to state that:
During 2007, The 4th PSYOP Group will dedicate the new Media Operations Complex in memory of First Lieutenant Michael A. Merkel. The proposed memorialization plaque reads 1LT Merkel made the ultimate sacrifice for his nation and the people of the R
. His sacrifice will serve to inspire all PSYOP dissemination soldiers, past, present, and future as to the significance and dangers of their mission. epublicof Vietnam
Pleiku Radio Listening Range
A report dated 25 January 1970 mentions the range of the Pleiku radio:
Letter received from listeners give some indication of the listening range of the radio. In early 1969 when the radio broadcast at low power (15,000 watts) 78 letters were received that suggest the range of the radio at low power extends to a radius of 260 miles. In late 1969 Radio Pleiku broadcast at high power (50,000 watts). Letters suggest the range was beyond 260 miles. It is safe to assume that at both low and high power, most of Vietnam is within listening range.
I should also point out the great confusion of studying
Gary L Grunow writes to say that:
The radio Station was under the 4th Group Headquarters and not the 8th PSYOP Battalion. The Radio Station Commander from 1970 - 1971 was Captain James Hlay. He led a separate detachment of about 30 people. Their barracks was on Artillery Hill outside of Pleiku. They also maintained living quarters at the radio site.
I suspect that everyone is correct and the radio station was a joint effort with the 7th Group handling logistics and training, the 4th Group in overall charge of broadcasting, and perhaps some members of the 10th assigned to the station. It is interesting to note that everyone has a different idea of who was running the radio operation.
Jones adds in Veritas:
The next morning, Radio Hanoi bragged about the successful attack against The Voice radio station. MACV was determined to get the station back on the air as soon as possible. The 7th PSYOP Group in Okinawa quickly responded by shipping a replacement antenna and radio modules to Vietnam. Civilian contractors were flown in from the United States to set up the radio antenna. With all of the radio modules replaced and the antenna up, The Voice was back on the air ten days after the 24 March attack.
6th PSYOP Battalion
LTC Raymond Deitch, Commander 6th PSYOP Battalion
In III Corps, the 6th PSYOP Battalion of the 4th PSYOP Group was formed in Saigon from the former 6th PSYOP Bn's 246th PSYOP Company. The new battalion was commanded by Major Clarence A. Binkley, the former company commander. In 1969 the battalion flag was transferred to Bien Hoa, although the 6th PSYOP Bn forces remained in Saigon until they departed Vietnam on 30 June 1971. Company A was the headquarters and administrative element; Company B was the field operations unit, with small PSYOP teams assigned to different infantry divisions of USARV in III Corps and IV Corps.The booklet continues:
10th Psychological Operations Battalion O Club, Can Tho, 1968.
The Professional Litterbugs of the 6th PSYOP Battalion in Bien Hoa have a long and proud record of achievement. They carry on the tradition of the old 6th Battalion, which was reorganized into the 4th PSYOP Group in December of 1967. The Meritorious Unit Commendation was awarded to the 6th Battalion in June 1968 for consummate skill in providing psychological operations support to allied forces. The personnel of the Battalion live and work on the Honour-Smith compound, a short distance from Bien Hoa airfield. The compound offers many recreational facilities including a newly constructed club and athletic equipment. One of the unique responsibilities of the battalion is its support of elements of the Royal Thai Armys Black Panther Division. The division, which arrived in-country during the summer of 1968, receives assistance in support of Civic Action programs as well as during military operations. Providing PSYOP support to all of III Corps tactical zone, the men of the 6th PSYOP Battalion continue to maintain their high level of pride and devotion.
A PSYOP Mobile Audiovisual Information Collection and Dissemination System (MSQ-85) waiting for the ferry on the dock at Can Tho. The MSQ-85 was the primary system in the U.S. inventory designated for tactical point dissemination of video products in other-than-broadcast mode. The AN/MSQ-85 includes a printing press, an AQ-4A movie projector, AN/UIH-6 loudspeaker public address system, AP-9 slide projector, AN/USH two-track international standard tape recorder, BM-22A large projection screen and R-520A/UUR radio receiver, a case of hand grenades, three cases of C-rations, a roll of toilet paper, and a generator. The trailer in the back could have anything from leaflets, magazines, and gifts of soap, to 105mm rounds (full of leaflets).
The Battalions official report states that the 246th PSYOP Company was officially deactivated on 31 December 1967 to become the 6th Psychological Operations Battalion on 1 January 1968. The battalion colors were presented to Major Clarence A. Barkley, the 6th PSYOP Battalion Commander by the 4th PSYOP Group Commander on 5 January 1968 at Bien Hoa. The 6th PSYOP Battalion moved its residence from the Train Compound to the Honour-Smith Compound on the 28th of January 1968. The move was made due to expected increase in unit strength and the present lack of adequate space at the Train Compound. The 6th Psychological Operations Battalion reported these quarterly production totals: Leaflets printed: 49,800,000; Leaflets disseminated: 372, 800,000; Loudspeaker broadcasts: 1,425 hours and 40 minutes; Total missions: 1002. Of the 20 officers assigned to the 6th Battalion, 14 had formal PSYOP training. The remaining 6 were enrolled in after-hours study course. A small Viet Cong propaganda printing press was presented to the 6th PSYOP Battalion by the 5th Special Forces Group.
10th PSYOP Battalion
In IV Corps, the 10th PSYOP Battalion of the 4th PSYOP Group was formed from the 19th PSYOP Company at Can Tho. It was officially Constituted 7 November 1967 in the Regular Army as the 10th Psychological Operations Battalion and Activated 1 December 1967. It continued operations until it departed Vietnam and was inactivated 17 April 1971 at Fort Lewis, Washington. The 10th Battalion maintained 15 field units, at Bac Lieu, Ben Tre, Ca Mau, Cao Lanh, Chau Doc, Dong Tam, Go Cong, Long Xuyen, Moc Hoa, My Tho, Rach Gia, Sa Dec, Soc Trang, Tra Vinh, and Vinh Long. Headquarters had 4 presses located at "Villa Cruz" that could produce 3-color leaflets in press runs of about 100,000. Larger runs (and repetitive runs like Chu Hoi and B-52 leaflets) were usually printed by the 7th PSYOP Group in Okinawa. Two 80kw generators were located there and one ran around the clock to power the presses and operate fans and light boxes for developing the run plates. The officers club was up on the roof of the Villa Cruz. Not to be outdone, the enlisted billet located in Ben Xi Moi had it's own club on their roof.
According to the Operations Report Lessons Learned Headquarters 10th Psychological Operations Battalion period ending 31 January, 1968 dated 6 February 1968 the 10th PSYOP Battalion dealt with a group known as the KKK, a quasi-bandit guerrilla band of Cambodian extract operating along the Cambodian border in Chau Doc province. The KKK was organized in company and battalion levels and constituted a threat to the local government and administration by taxing the people and in some instances attacking villages and assassinating leaders. Between 24 December 1967 and 3 January 1968, 185 of these KKK bandits rallied to the GVN. An arrangement was worked out by province officials and they offered full Chieu Hoi type benefits to the KKK members although current GVN policy does not classify the KKK as being eligible. Seizing the possibility of influencing the KKK personnel of the 10th POB dispatched 2 field teams to the area to determine conditions and make leaflet and loudspeaker appeals.
The 10th flew 5 or more leaflet-drop missions per day, using two C47 aircraft and U-10 HelioCouriers. The USAF 5th SOS located at Binh Thuy Vietnamese Air Force Base had two C47 Gooney Birds plus six U-10 Super HelioCouriers.) These were also used elsewhere in IV Corps. The unit was awarded the Meritorious Unit Commendation (Army) for Vietnam 1967-1968, and the Republic of Vietnam Civil Action Honor Medal, First Class for Vietnam 1967-1970.
Another interesting mission occurred in January 1968 when a study was completed and plans were formulated for a project to reach the population of tightly controlled Viet Cong areas by means of attractive waterproof jackets containing leaflets and brochures along with gifts (soap, thread and needles, tooth brushes, crayons, etc.) floated into the targeted areas by means of numerous canals and waterways of IV Corps. Arrangements were made with the Binh Thay Naval Base S5 (Civil Affairs) to supply the 10th POB with detailed intelligence of the targeted groups in the river target areas and a means of delivery. A search was made for a source of cellophane bags and a bag sealer.
The 10th PSYOP Battalion HQ building in Can Tho, following an attack in January 1968.
(Photos courtesy of Rick Hofmann)
The 10th flew 5 or more leaflet-drop missions per day, using two C47 aircraft and U-10 HelioCouriers. The USAF 5th SOS located at Binh Thuy Vietnamese Air Force Base had two C47 "Gooney Birds" plus six U-10 Super HelioCouriers.) These were also used elsewhere in IV Corps. The unit was awarded the Meritorious Unit Commendation (Army) for Vietnam 1967-1968, and the Republic of Vietnam Civil Action Honor Medal, First Class for Vietnam 1967-1970.
10th PSYOP Battalion "Order of the Delta Psywarrior" Certificate
Colonel Robert L. Gleason discusses the Air Force contribution in
In 1961, in response to President Kennedys order to all services to bolster their counterinsurgency capability, the USAF established the 4400th Combat Crew Training Squadron. Known as Jungle Jim, it later became the 1st Air Commando Squadron and finally evolved into the present Special Operations Air Force. Its original mission gave high priority to the conduct of psychological operations. Because of scarcity of experience in PSYOP, the Jungle Jim personnel turned to the
US for some accelerated instruction in the subject. On 15 November 1961 they deployed to Army Special Warfare Center . On 4 December they flew our first PSYOP mission in C-47s equipped with belly-mounted loudspeakers. South Vietnam
The first USAF crew lost in
was probably on a PSYOP mission. On 10 February a Farm Gate C-47 carrying USAF and USA instructors, together with Vietnamese personnel, distributed leaflets bearing Tet greetings from RVN President Diem to numerous villages between Da Nang and Saigon. Upon landing at Tan Son Nhut, the aircraft was discovered to have picked up several bullet holes. The program called for a return flight the following day over the same villages to deliver another Tet message, this time from President Kennedy. The crew, not knowing where the ground fire was picked up but anxious to complete the two-phase PSYOP project, elected to fly the return mission. It was on this flight that the aircraft was lost north of Da Lat, causing the death of its joint (USAF-USA) and combined (U.S.Vietnamese) crew. South Vietnam
U.S. Navys Mobile Riverine Force
The booklet adds:
From its headquarters in the heart of the Mekong Delta, the 10th PSYOP Battalion coordinates PSYOP support for allied military operations throughout the IV Corps tactical Zone. The 10th PSYOP Battalion, located in the bustling city of Can Tho, maintains two billets and one headquarters compound for its operations. The Villa Cruz houses the printing facility as well as the officers quarters and Battalion S-4 section. The New Villa is home for the units enlisted men and non-commissioned officers. The command section and S-1, S-2, S-3 and PDC sections are located on the second floor of the Civil Operations Rural Development (CORDS)* PSYOP Building. Here, all analysis and development of propaganda is accomplished including graphical illustrations and testing. Seven close support platoons are fielded by the battalion throughout the provinces of IV Corps. Broken down into two man teams, they work closely with CORDS and other representatives to give quick reaction support. One of the most unique field teams operates with the U.S. Navys Mobile Riverine Force during operations conducted on the waterways of the Delta. Using gigantic loudspeaker systems, the psywarriors coax the enemy from his hiding places along the thickly wooded shoreline.
A Swabbie Santa comes to Vietnam
The photo above shows a USN Civic Action mission. Pham thi Bac (now Bac thi Eaton),
perhaps the only Vietnamese female to hold full membership in both the Game-Wardens and
* Dale Andrade discussed the CORDS program in an article called Three Lessons
There must be a unified structure that combines military and civilian pacification efforts. In
that organization was called CORDS, for Civil Operations and Rural Development Support. Formed in 1967, it placed the disjointed and ineffective civilian pacification programs under the military. This was accomplished only at the insistence of President Lyndon Johnson, who took an active interest in seeing the pacification process function smoothly under a single manager: Gen. William Westmoreland. CORDS gave the pacification effort access to military money and personnel, allowing programs to expand dramatically. In 1966 there were about 1,000 advisers involved in pacification, and the annual budget was $582 million; by 1969 that had risen to 7,600 advisers and almost $1.5 billion. This rapid progress was possible only because of CORDS's streamlined system under Defense Department control. Vietnam
Printing of propaganda by the 4th PSYOP Group was done in Vietnam, at Group headquarters in Saigon, and in facilities at each company and battalion headquarters. The 4th PSYOP Group used the offshore services of the 7th PSYOP Group for large printing jobs.
According to the booklet:
The mission of the 4th Psychological Operations Group is to provide psychological Operations in support of all U.S. military operations and internal development programs in the Republic of Vietnam.
The 4th Psychological Operations Group is organized as shown in Table of Equipment (TOE) 33-500F, 18 September 1967. The Group headquarters (in Saigon) includes a Headquarters Company. Each battalion has a close support company containing loudspeaker and audio-visual teams and a general support company containing a print plant. The Group headquarters and each battalion have the conventional S-1, S-2, S-3, and S-4 staff sections, plus a Psychological Operations Development Center (PDC). The PDC system throughout the Group is the "core" for Group propaganda operations.
With an authorized strength of 880 American military personnel, 133 Vietnamese civilian personnel and 78 Army of the Republic of Vietnam interpreters, the Group is comprised of the 6th, 7th, 8th and 10th PSYOP Battalionsone in each of the "corps tactical zones" of Vietnam.
The early history of the 4th Psychological Operations Group is actually the history of the 6th Psychological Operations Battalion. During the early phases of the Vietnam build up in the spring of 1965, PSYOP detachments began arriving from Okinawa and Fort Bragg. The 6th Psychological Operations Battalion Headquarters arrived in country on 5 February 1966. The battalion headquarters took control of the various detachments, which were organized into three companies. These companies, the 244th, 245th, and 246th were located in I Corps, II Corps, and III Corps respectively. In November of 1966, the 19th PSYOP Company was deployed to Vietnam to be assigned to the battalion and located in IV Corps.
On December 1, 1967, the 6th PSYOP Battalion was reorganized into the 4th PSYOP Group. At the same time, three of the companies became battalions, the 7th PSYOP Battalion (formerly the 244th PSYOP Company), the 8th PSYOP Battalion (formerly the 245th PSYOP Company), and 10th PSYOP Battalion (formerly the 19th PSYOP Company). The 6th PSYOP Battalion (formerly the 246th PSYOP Company) became the fourth battalion in the Group, located in Bien Hoa.
The booklet goes on to tell of some operations:
Hundreds of newly-assigned 4th Group psyoperators reflect the growing intensity of the psychological operations effort in Vietnam. The past year produced substantial evidence of the effectiveness of the 4th PSYOP Group operations in countering communist aggression is Southeast Asia. Examples typical of these operations: In June 1968, 4th PSYOP Group field teams and helicopter loudspeakers scored a record 135 enemy defections during a Communist offensive in the Saigon suburb of Gia Dinh.
Tactical Loudspeaker Team with interpreter
US Soldier in photo is Jack O'Neil
(Photo courtesy of Rick Hofmann)
The booklet explains the missions of the four PSYOP Battalions:
The battalion mission in each corps tactical zone is two-fold; first, to provide psychological operations support to all U.S. combat units. This support includes the use of field teams equipped with powerful ground loudspeakers and audio-visual equipment. Habitually operating with front-line fighting units, loudspeaker teams provide close support in tactical operations and are highly successful in this role. Secondly, the battalions are required to support non-military "pacification" or internal development" programs. For example, they employ audio-visual jeepsters in support of revolutionary development, civic action and medical aid projects and programs throughout Vietnam. This later role appears to be an ever-increasing one for the 4th PSYOP Group.
Field teams of the Group have been part of every major combat operation in Vietnam since February 1966, including Operations Cedar Falls, Byrd, Hastings and Manhattan.
The battalions work closely with the Air Force 14th Special Operations Wing, elements of which are co-located with the PSYOP Battalions. The Special Operations Squadrons fly leaflet and loudspeaker missions, which are requested and targeted by the battalions.
C-47 Dropping Leaflets
The booklet then explains the resources of the group to the new troops:
Aircraft are the primary means of distribution of psychological operation leaflets in the Republic of Vietnam. They are also used for aerial loudspeaker broadcasts. Aircraft used in dissemination are the C-47, U-10, and O-2B. Other means of PSYOP support include broadcasts from small naval vessels and helicopters and ground loudspeaker operations conducted by Group field teams serving with front-line combat units.
The 4th PSYOP Group headquarters has two Mobile Advisory Teams, which are designed to react immediately to any PSYOP situation. These teams also conduct instruction on PSYOP techniques for all allied units requiring such help. They also evaluate low-level PSYOP programs and make recommendations on ways of improving these efforts. A Mobile Advisory Team in each battalion performs similar functions.
Loudspeaker also supported hamlet operations
Aerial loudspeaker in C-47 aircraft
(Photo courtesy of Dave Boyers)
The Group as well as each of its subordinate battalions, has the capability of producing taped messages for loudspeaker and radio dissemination.
Psychological Operations Development Centers (PDC) comprise the system for development of propaganda throughout the Group. The headquarters PDC was organized in December 1967. Presently each battalion and separate company maintains its own PDC, which is an extension of the headquarters center.
Psychological Operations Development Center (PDC)
The PDC systematically analyses the target audiences and carefully develops messages with the proper impact. Another PDC responsibility is the careful critique of all materials requested by outside agencies. All propaganda is carefully checked for compliance with Policy Guidance and validity of layout and message content. These procedures are often completed within one day of receipt of the materials to be tested. The PDC employs social scientists, area (cultural) experts, writers, artists and illustrators.
PSYOP Illustrator prepares the graphic for a new leaflet. Finished leaflet at right
PSYOP Print Press
The Group Headquarters provides general support to the battalions. Installed at the newly enlarged headquarters printing plant are three Hess and Barker web-fed presses, three Multilith 1250 presses and three automatic paper cutters. Battalion printing capabilities are organic to the battalion general support company. Multilith 1250 presses are the battalions primary means of reproduction, while the Multilith 85 press is sometimes used for quick reaction materials.
Photo processing truck
(Photo courtesy of Dave Boyers)
Passing out newspapers
The booklet concludes:
Newspapers and newsletters are produced by the thousands for a news hungry rural population. The 2-billionth leaflet emerged from the clamoring presses of the Groups Headquarters printing facility in May and the 3-billionth leaflet was printed in November 1968. In several battalions, Vietnamese Armed Propaganda Teams are used in face-to-face communications and accompany Group loudspeaker and audio-visual teams in close support operations and propaganda missions to hamlets.
On the subject of armed propaganda teams, JUSPAO leaflet 3123 depicts an entire marching company of Vietnamese APTs, each with a loudspeaker under his right arm. To the right of the photograph is a Chieu Hoi symbol and the text:
Return to alleviate the suffering of the people.
The back is all text:
The Chieu Hoi Cadres of Long An Province. Deeply encouraged by the success of the Chieu Hoi program, the armed propaganda teams of long An welcomes the prime Minister and Vietnamese government officials to long An. The event was the opening ceremony of the Spring for the fatherland campaign. The aim of the Chieu hoi program is to urge those still on the other side to return to their families and alleviate the sorrows of separation.
Armed Propaganda Team Member passing out leaflets
The 69-page APT Handbook issued to American advisors attached to Vietnamese armed propaganda teams. The handbook covers such subjects as; force structure and allocation, recruitment, operations, training, logistical support, finance, and all the other areas important for a force in the field
7th PSYOP Group
The 7th PSYOP Group was constituted 19 August 1965 in the regular Army and activated 20 October 1965 and assigned to the Ryukyu Islands, located in the Machinato Service Area. It was attached to IX Corps for operation and Training. The 7th PSYOP Group was the successor to the U. S. Army Broadcasting and Visual Activity, Pacific, (USABVAPAC) which was disbanded 20 October 1965. The 7th assumed all missions and functions previously administered by USABVAPAC and transferred members and equipment.
The 7th PSYOP Group was tasked with support activities in Okinawa, Vietnam, Taiwan, Korea and Japan. The group consisted of the 14th PSYOP Battalion, the 15th PSYOP Detachment, the Japan Detachment, the Korea detachment, the Taiwan Detachment, and the Vietnam Detachment.
In Vietnam the Group worked in support of the Commander, United States Military Assistance Command, Vietnam (COMUSMACV). A twoman team consisting of a liaison officer and an NCO arrived in Vietnam on 20 October 1965 and remained after the 4th PSYOP Group was formed. At one time more than 80 people from the 7th PSYOP Group were on TDY in Vietnam. Throughout the war, the duties of the 7th PSYOP Group included the provision of PSYOP liaison and offshore printing support for South Vietnam.
During 1965 The Okinawa printing plant produced 125 million leaflets for MACV and the Vietnam Detachment produced another 62 million on its web-fed press in Saigon. The Detachment maintained liaison with the Joint United States Public Affairs Office and the Military Assistance Command Political Warfare Directorate. In September two members journeyed to Vietnam to plan and conduct the first high altitude leaflet and toy bundle dissemination over North Vietnam. They returned again in December to assist in a Christmas toy drop over North Vietnam.
In 1967 the unit was awarded the Meritorious Unit Commendation for their support of military operations. Besides the units mentioned earlier, the 7th PSYOP Group added a Radio Detachment (Provisional) Vietnam. The unit now had 41 linguists who were proficient in 11 different languages. During 1967 they printed 7 billion propaganda leaflets for Vietnam and Korea. Their printing capability was enhanced by using the U. S. Army Printing and Production Center in Tokyo, and the Regional Service Center of the United States Information agency in Manila.
PSYOP Loudspeaker Truck
The small detachments Vietnam HQs were bombed by the VC in December of 1966 and they moved to 8 Vinh Vien Street. Later they moved to 16 Pham Ngu Lao in the Cholon section of Saigon. They coordinated the activities of four loudspeaker teams, supervised two leaflet dissemination courses, and assisted members who were on temporary duty (TDY) with MACVSOG. Their motto was "Credibility Through Communication."
The Vietnam Detachment, established by the 7th PSYOP Group, operated from Saigon, where, on 3 February 1969, it was officially designated the 244th PSYOP Detachment of the 7th PSYOP Group. Later, this detachment became a company within the 7th PSYOP Group.
7th PSYOP Group Loudspeaker Jeep
Leaflet Mix 249 was the last number used by MACV; Mix 250 begins 7th PSYOP Group control. Leaflet Mixes 239-248 had been previously assigned to the 7th PSYOP Group. (Memo dated 4 July 1972).
Leaflet 4508 was the last number used by MACV; leaflet 4509 begins 7th PSYOP Group control.
After the Vietnam War, the 7th PSYOP Group was deactivated for a time. In the mid-1970s, it was revived as a headquarters for the 353rd and 306th PSYOP Battalions, the 1st PSYOP Company, and the 15th PSYOP Company, all located in California. During this period, the 7th PSYOP Group was located in San Francisco, and reported to the 351st CA Command, which was an ARCOM-level USAR element.
After the 244th PSYOP Detachment of the 7th PSYOP Group became a company, it was commanded by Maj. (later Col.) David G. Underhill.
The psywar operation in Vietnam involved complex civilian and military arrangements, and was enormous in scope and confusing in structure. In addition to JUSPAO, MACV, and the 4th and 7th PSYOP Groups, other American units conducting psywar operations in Vietnam include the U.S. Embassy Mission PSYOP Committee, Civil Operations and Revolutionary Development Support, the U.S. Army-Vietnam (USARV), force commanders and senior advisers, U.S. Naval Forces-Vietnam, III Marine Amphibious Force (who held original responsibility for I Corps), and the 7th U.S. Army Force. Psychological operations in Vietnam was sometimes termed "a many-splintered thing."(Arts and Science,Vol. 1, no year)
Despite the confusion and complexity of the allied psywar operations, the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong became targets of what would prove to be the largest psychological operation to date. For example, in 1969 alone, no less than 10.5 billion leaflets were distributed by JUSPAO.
Barger mentions the enormous amount of leaflets produced:
As PSYOP forces shifted emphasis toward support to Pacification efforts and related programs, such as Phoenix, the net effect on the overall PSYOP mission was not a change in tasks but an addition to tasks. For example, by the third quarter of 1969, the 4th PSYOP Groups in-country printing elements produced over 595 million leaflets, nearly 100 million of those for Joint U.S. Public Affairs Office, the Vietnamese General Political Warfare Directorate, and other Government of Vietnam agencies To understand how this entails an expanded scale of printing requirements, consider that it took the 4th PSYOP Group's print facility 28 months to print their two-billionth leaflet in May 1968, but they printed their three-billionth in November, only seven months later. As this expansion of requirements reached the limit of military PSYOP capabilities, the force underwent additional structural changes and relied more heavily on offshore support from the 7th PSYOP Group and other agencies, and was forced to prioritize their efforts when demands exceeded capabilities. Related structural and personnel changes in CORDS, JUSPAO, and MACV would influence PSYOP priorities even more in the coming years.
Before we leave this look at Allied PSYOP against the Communists in Vietnam we should study what the Viet Cong thought of the American and Republic of Vietnams propaganda campaigns waged against their forces. There are numerous such reports produced during the length of the war as enemy documents were captured and translated. One such document is a JUSPAO Field Memorandum dated 27 August 1966. It is a Viet Cong internal document which is a memorandum from a high headquarters (probably the Central Committee of the People's Revolutionary Party) to its interzone and provincial level agit-prop units throughout the country:
At present, the enemy is using psywar to attack us on the ideological plane. He has scattered many leaflets from aircraft and has appealed to us through (loudspeaker) broadcasts. The objective of this is to destroy our morale. The themes of this propaganda are these: rally to the enemy side; the war causes much misery; U.S. weapons are very powerful and they menace us; rewards will be given those who leave their friends and abandon their mission; the South Vietnamese army soldiers have much honor and (monetary) benefits, and the enemy side is the side of authority.
These efforts surely influence our troops. If we do not closely control cadre and soldier thoughts, we shall face many difficulties. For this is a dangerous wicked scheme by the enemy. It is related to the general war situation, all aimed at reducing the fighting spirit of our forces and having a great influence on our struggle toward victory in general, and during this summer in particular.
Appropriate measures to counter enemy propaganda are:
1. Carefully indoctrinate troops, cadres and soldiers about the enemy's psywar schemes. Make clear to all people the fact of his corruption and that he pretends to be very strong but cannot hide his failures; that our people will gain victory. Make cadres and soldiers understand the glory of a revolutionary soldier. Make everybody energetic and cause them deeply to resent the enemy and be determined to fight and win all battles under all circumstances. "
2. Whenever the enemy uses psywar, cadres should immediately hold indoctrination sessions and closely manage the people's thoughts and actions. Be prepared for all developments. When leaflets drop, all people, even the cadres and soldiers should tear them up without reading them. Only cadre chiefs are authorized to read and then explain and analyze the contents of the leaflets to the cadres and to soldiers in their units. The latter are prohibited from reporting on the contents of this propaganda to others, or to discuss it. To discuss enemy propaganda is to voluntarily or involuntarily propagandize for the enemy. Set up a self-improved spirit in each unit so that cadres and soldiers help each other.
The two approaches to be employed, therefore, are indoctrination and denial of access to the materials.
Soldiers of the 9th Division
The first PSYOP units appeared in Vietnam about June 1965. It was almost February 1966 before they were really organized and running smoothly. There were already some combat units on the ground and they produced propaganda leaflets, although it is unknown if they did this internally, or used teams of people trained in PSYOP. The 1st Infantry Division arrived in Vietnam about October 1965 and apparently prepared Propaganda leaflets either without code or actually coded 1st Inf. The leaflet above is numbered #15, which seems to imply 14 earlier leaflets. The very crude image shows Viet Cong being killed by an artillery blast at the left while one guerrilla runs away. At the right the guerrilla shakes hand with a soldier from the 1st Division. The text is:
Soldiers of the 9th Division
You are in the operating area of the powerful 1st U.S. Infantry Division. We know you are southeast of Minh-Thanh. More units of the 1st Infantry Division will be upon you. Surrender or die. If you want to surrender; remove your shirts, sling your weapons muzzle down, and put your hands behind your neck. Then report to the first soldier you see.
Surrender now or die under the power of the 1st Infantry Division.
Special campaigns postcards and letters
Besides the regular leaflets, handbills and posters, occasionally the PSYOP troops would partake in special campaigns. Two that are of particular interest are leaflets made in the form of either postcards or stamped letters.
JUSPAO postcard 2904B.
This postcard was prepared in January 1969 as part of a Chieu Hoi (Open Arms) and Tet (New Year) campaign. The target was the Viet Cong and their relatives and sympathizers. It was a one-time item and not available for re-order. The same vignette was used on a poster coded 2902 which had an additional seven photographs of citizens working to improve the nation. The postcard depicts a Vietnamese mother and daughter watching some children light holiday firecrackers. The official title is Postcard of Tet Poster No. 1, 1969. The back of the postcard is blank. The text is:
HAPPY NEW YEAR LONGING FOR PEACE
Leaflet 8-319 (1.14)
This Chieu Hoi postcard was dropped during Tet 1969 by Captain Albert Yanus
of the 5th Special Operations Squadron from an HC-47d flying out of Bien Hoa AFB. The
3 1/2 x 5-inch blank-back cards were dropped in III Corps, the densely populated alluvial
Happy New Year
Fun with language - A Vietnamese-language linguist told me that the literal translation of the four words is Wishing [you a] New Spring. I asked what might be a better translation. He said Happy New Year. I told him Wasnt that what I said?
Major Michael G. Barger says about the annual Tet campaigns which first showed great success in 1966:
The 1967 Tet Campaign began on 11 January and continued through the end of February. The combined effort included dropping over 300 million leaflets, loudspeaker broadcasts using over two thousand different taped appeals, and both radio and television broadcasts. MACV, though acknowledging in their 1967 Command History that, the Tet campaign was not solely responsible, still determined that these efforts largely accounted for the record monthly high Hoi Chanh figure of 2,917 in February 1967. This perceived success led MACV to continue Februarys campaign into March, dropping 87 million leaflets calling for a Spring
Reunion along with 27 million safe conduct passes.
The Joint U.S. Public Affairs Office used the same image (minus the Chieu Hoi symbol) on a leaflet coded SP-2-67. The message says in part:
New Year is coming to the country. While the people living under the control of the Government of South Vietnam are preparing to celebrate a New Year, they are also thinking about the miseries suffered by the people living under Viet Cong domination Please think of the benefits of the Open Army program and encourage your children who are now in the Viet Cong to return to South Vietnam.
There are at least three PSYOP products on card stock that the American military calls
stationery. In all three cases the backs are blank, but it seems apparent that
the products were meant to be used as postcards. In all three cases the items were
prepared by the Joint
Postcard 1668A depicts Le Loi, a legendary hero of
FOLLOW THE EXAMPLE OF HERO LE LOI
Promote the unyielding spirit of the Vietnamese People in the
destruction of Communism and salvation of the country.
The statue of Le Loi stands in front of the Municipal Hall of Thanh Hoa Province where he was born. Le Loi was emperor of Vietnam and founder of the Le dynasty. He is among the most famous figures of Vietnamese history and one of its greatest heroes.
Postcard 1707A depicts Tran Hung Dao, a legendary hero of
FOLLOWING THE EXAMPLE OF TRAN HUNG DAO
All the people unite to fight against Communism to save the nation
A 1967 Army paper entitled Vietnamese Superstitions mentions this campaign:
PSYOP use of the venerated figure of Tran Hung Dao, victor in 1285 over the Golden Horde led by Kublai Khans Chinese vassal satisfies all requirements. We know the supernatural qualities with which the heroic figure of Tan Hung Dao is endowed in the popular mind, and the Government of Vietnam has the capability of invoking him in patriotic appeals aimed against the invaders (See JUSPAO poster 1271) which are among the most popular produced in the PSYOP field to date.
This same image was used on several other leaflets. For instance, two uncut leaflets were disseminated without code and on the back was a message from the Province Chief of Binh Thuan Province to the 840th Viet Cong Main Force Battalion. The leaflets were not separated so a longer message could be placed on the back. The 840th battalion had attacked Binh Thuan during the Tet 1968 offensive. The Province Chief Nguyen Khac sent a Tet greeting and a message of peace.
An even stranger leaflet was three uncut leaflets with the code SP-170. The message on the back of this leaflet is a request from the residents of Suoi-Nghe village for the arrest and punishment of the Viet Cong who had murdered two village leaders.
Postcard 2592 depicts a heroic Vietnamese soldier charging forward with his flag waving behind him. A smaller version is coded 2592A and the Cambodian version is coded 2592B. The text is:
WE ARE DETERMINED TO DEFEND THE NATION
Pack of Vietnamese Cigarettes
We have all heard the old What came first, the chicken or the egg? In this case, what came first, the Propaganda postcard or the Vietnamese cigarettes with the same image on the front?
Mike Fisher who is a veteran of Vietnam from 1971-1972 in the 544th transportation Company in Chu Lai, and D Company, 87th Infantry Regiment in Da Nang, wrote to tell me:
I got in the habit of smoking Ruby Queen cigarettes when I ran out of American smokes. I pulled security for the different cargo shipping areas in and around Da Nang. I was doing the work of an 11 Bravo infantry grunt, a lot of guard duty and roving patrols. There were several different boat ramps and the deep water pier for ocean-going ships. Sometimes I would get gate guard duty at the Bridge Ramp, Tiensha Ramp or the deep water pier. One of my duties was to work with the ARVN and civilians. I frequently spent a lot of time with them and some of the village elders, and would share food, drink and smokes. So I liked the Ruby Queens. They were very strong.
Leaflet 14a Front
Although not actual postcards or letters, there are two leaflets that appear to be
stamped postcards. They are from the same series and are coded 14a and 14b which indicates
that they were prepared to be dropped during the campaign against
To a North Vietnamese Compatriot
Leaflet 14b Front.
Leaflet 14b back
The fake stamps are cancelled
You and I are Vietnamese living on the soil of
. Circumstances, unfortunately, keep you in the North and me in the South. Vietnam
When your communist rulers cut the country in two, close to one million of our compatriots fled the Communist Zone for the South. Since that sad day, we have been living peacefully, busying ourselves with rebuilding the country and establishing a free and democratic regime in the South.
Unfortunately, for the past ten years the Communists of the North have been waging war in the South with the aim of imposing Communist rule on the free part of our country. Men and weapons have been infiltrated to the South to destroy schools, hospitals, roads and bridges, and kill innocent civilians. In doing this, your Communist rulers claim to liberate the southern people. But, we have never asked them to liberate us. In fact, what do we want to be liberated from? We are happy with what we have and wish only to be left alone.
But, it is obvious that your Communist rulers are unmoved by our desire for peace.
Now, in face of stepped-up infiltration of men and weapons to intensify the aggressive was against the South, we are compelled to act in self defense. We are bombing the military installations and communication facilities which your Communist rulers are using to sustain their war of aggression in the South.
So, for your safety, please stay away from these targets.
My letter is short but my sentiments are immense. I am cordially yours.
The first record I have of this leaflet being dropped is 20 July 1965. American and
Vietnamese aircraft dropped the leaflets over communication routes heading to Hanoi and
Haiphong, as well as eight North Vietnamese cities. The leaflets were mixed with numbers
13 and 16 and a total of 3,360,000 of the three were disseminated. Another 520,000 of 14a
and 14b were dropped on 30 July 1965 over Van Yen, Ba Don and Huong Khe. On 9 December
another 480,000 were dropped over the
The Trung Sisters
Because the Trung sisters were national heroes in Vietnam, they were often placed on PSYOP leaflets and posters. The Trung Sisters led the first resistance movement against the occupying Chinese after 247 years of domination. Many temples are dedicated to them and their death is commemorated each year. Legend says that in 39 AD they gathered an army of 80,000, led by 36 women generals and within a year drove the Chinese occupiers from 65 cities. Because they had liberated their country, they were named co-queens. The Chinese returned with a huge force and after defeat on the battleground the sisters committed suicide by drowning themselves in 43 AD. A Fifteenth Century poem says about the sisters: All the male heroes bowed their heads in submission; only the two sisters proudly stood up to avenge the country. The text on the poster is:
Oppose the Communists' aggression in defense of our liberties as
of the Hong Lac race.
Do as the two Trung sisters of the Trieu family did.
Note: The sisters renamed their country Hong Lac during their reign. Some experts believe that Hong represented their clan and Lac the ethnic group from which the Vietnamese descended. Others think the Hong Lac race moved down from the north about 4,000 years ago. The term might be mythical in nature.
There are a great number of leaflets that try to glorify the image of the government of the Republic of Vietnam or the United States. This 1968 8th PSYOP Battalion leaflet depicts a peaceful scene of a rice paddy on one side and a Vietnamese man looking over the countryside on the other. It is meant to glorify the Vietnamese Government. The text is:
I am a citizen, born and living in Vietnam. I love my country. I love green rice fields, buffaloes grazing in the grass, birds singing beyond bamboo trees, thatched roofs with smoke in the sunset. You and we are brothers, born and living in Vietnam in the same native land. Why should we fight each other? Could we not support the same government? The Government of the Republic of Vietnam is the government of Vietnam and our government.
This leaflet was prepared to lift the image of the United States. It depicts local Vietnamese going to a hospital to be treated by American medical personnel. It says in part:
There is no reason for you to suffer. If you are ill or in need of medical care join with the hundreds of Vietnamese civilians of Phu My District who receive expert medical attention from the medical aid station at LZ Uplift. Every day many people of the village of Phu My are treated by qualified medical personnel. If your illness warrants, you will be sent to Phu My Hospital for further treatment. If you can be treated by the 1st Battalion (mechanized) 50th Infantry aid station, we will provide you with medicine. Many patients return regularly for continued treatment. It is our desire to help our Vietnamese brothers. Bring your sick children to us so that our medical personnel can treat them.
Your brothers of the Ichiban Battalion.
That battalion name confused me. I knew from time in Japan that Ichiban meant number one. Why would an American unit have that name? A little research showed that it did in fact belong to the 1st Battalion, 50th Infantry, the 2nd Armored Division.
This 1968 7th PSYOP Battalion leaflet was also meant to build the image of the U.S. One side depicts an American soldier shaking hands with a Vietnamese and the other shows a Vietnamese working in the fields. The text is:
U.S. Soldiers are you friends; they help to secure you safety. When they come, if you run away, it is very difficult for them to distinguish innocent people from the Viet Cong. Do not run away; continue to do your work
There were dozens of different leaflets asking the people to inform on the whereabouts of the Viet Cong. Many offered rewards and we mention them in a different article. In this very early JUSPAO leaflet from about 1962 the people are asked to inform just for their own general welfare and that of the nation. The front of the leaflet depicts farmers being forced to give the Viet Cong their rice and receiving worthless promissory notes in return. The text is:
Denounce the actions of the Viet Cong. Do not let the Viet Cong steal your rice and kidnap your sons and relatives. Denounce Viet Cong actions to the Army of the Government of the Republic of Vietnam.
The back of the leaflet depicts Vietnamese Army troops asking a farmer to tell them where the guerrillas are located. The farmer points in their direction. The text is:
Did you see any Viet Cong today? How many of them were there? Where were they? How many weapons did they have? Help the Government's Army restore peace and tranquility to Vietnam. Tell the Army about the Viet Cong and where they are hiding.
We find several American leaflets that hint that a good Communist soldier who defects in the South might find love. Curiously, the United States did the same thing in a highly classified secret operation that dropped leaflets over North Korea about the same time. The North Koreans spies and saboteurs infiltrated south and some American leaflets showed them other spies that had been captured or defected, found love and got married.
JUSPAO leaflet 2486 depicts North Vietnamese defector Tran Quang Huan and his South Vietnamese wife Cao Thi Chau. This leaflet was found by Sergeant Jim Hackbarth, a member of the 1st Platoon, Alpha Company, 1st Battalion of the 7th Cavalry, in 1970. He said: It is still smudged with the Red Dirt that was abundant around Quan loi. The text says in part:
FORMER NORTH VIETNAMESE SOLDIER MARRIES SOUTH VIETNAMESE LADY
Tran Quang Huan, a former North Vietnamese soldier who rallied is photographed with his Southern wife Cao Thi Chau. Mr. Huan and his wife live in a village established by more than 100 former North Vietnamese soldiers who are now free citizens in the Republic of Vietnam.
The back of the leaflet is a long message explaining all that will be given to the defector, including over $10,000 in Vietnamese banknotes to build a house, buy furniture, etc.
This leaflet features a more formal wedding of a Hoi Chanh to a South Vietnamese woman. The text on the front is:
A Returnees wedding at the Thi Nghe Open Arms Center
The long text on the back says in part:
BUILDING UP A NEW LIFE
A returnees wedding ceremony was solemnly held at the Thi Nghe Open Arms Center in the presence of the Centers director and other returnees living in the center. This is one of many weddings organized by the Thi Nghe Open Arms Center to help the returnees. Of both sexes, get married in order to build a new life in the Great Family of People.
The concept that the Government sees all and knows all was a very powerful PSYOP weapon. In later wars in Iraq and Afghanistan the USA prepared leaflets depicting a staring pair of eyes, or aircraft and even space satellites that watched the battlefield. The concept was to terrify the Guerrilla and make him think his every secret movement was being watched. In Vietnam, the 19th PSYOP Company prepared a series of leaflet targeting enemy units that had the same basic text in and told the enemy that they were under surveillance and even mentions the names of some unit leaders. Leaflet 19-13-67 targeted the B1004 Platoon; 19-28-67 targeted the Omon Company; 19-29-67 targeted the Thot Not Company; and 19-30-67 targeted the C-29 Company.
All the leaflets show a giant government soldier looking down at tiny Viet Cong guerrillas by a campfire. 100,000 leaflets were printed in black and white. The text on the front is:
Greeting to the Thot Not Company
The Republic of Vietnam warns you that you are being watched
Your activities and that of Platoon Leader Hai Cong and Assistant Platoon Leader Ba Chien are being clearly noted by the Biet Kich Our agents are everywhere!
The text on the back is the usual surrender message with offers of good treatment and open arms upon their return.
Note: Thot Not is a type of palm tree, and also a place name - the name of a district in the Can Tho area in the Mekong Delta. I assume the Viet Cong in the company came from that area. Biet Kich means "Commando." It is the term that the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army used for CIDG troops, the Civilian Irregular Defense Group. The CIDG program began in late 1961 as a counterinsurgency experiment in the central highlands of South Vietnam.
Leaflets 2107A, B and C
We dont know much about this leaflet that depicts the flag of the Republic of Vietnam since we do not see a code number. There is a message on the front which we translate here:
The Viet Cong are now embarrassing and humiliating our Fatherland. Following orders from Communist China, they are exploiting you all. Drive them out of your hamlets and neighborhoods. Do not allow them to use your homes to shoot at the government's army and its aircraft.
The Viet Cong are losing. The government's army will continue to seek out and destroy them until our national flag flies over every hamlet and every single home.
There are dozens of Vietnamese-language propaganda leaflets using poems. The
tradition of poetry is long and respected in
This leaflet uses poetry as a medium of communication. In fact, some of the best leaflets ever used in
have consisted of emotion-provoking poems, with suitable illustrations related to the thematic content of the poem. Vietnam
Poems frequently express nostalgia, sorrow and longing more effectively than is possible in prose. But the poetry must be good, or it will be scorned.
Do not use amateur poets; employ or use material from popular and well known poets.
The leaflet shows a sobbing mother at top left and her son in the South below. On the back the son is shown dead and alone in the jungle. It was prepared in November 1967 for distribution in I, II and III Corps areas. Some of the long text is:
From the day I left you, mother,
to follow my companions on the trip to
Central Vietnam through Laos,
I have endured the hardships of
climbing up the green mountains
And marching through rain and shine,
Although with my young age
life should blossom like a flower.
For the sake of peace I dont mind
Enduring hardships and danger.
For several months I marched during
the day and rested at night.
My shoes heels have worn out
And my jacket's shoulders
Were rubbed thin through which the cold slips in
A small box at the lower left in the back of the leaflet contains the text:
The above letter in poetry form was found on the body of a dead soldier of the Hanoi regime killed in the battle of Duc Co.
What is interesting about this poem is that it was memorized by a Vietnamese officer heading south. He mentions it in a debriefing after being captured, although his memory is a bit different from the official translation and he is probably paraphrasing some parts. This comment is from the debriefing of 2LT Nguyen Van Thong, a soldier in the 320th Regiment, 1st PAVN Division, who fought in Kontum Province in March-April 1968. PSYOP troops must have hated the first part where he says their leaflets are not very good, but cheered at the second part where he admits he memorized the poem on one leaflet:
I have seen very many PSYOP leaflets but they are very poor and we laugh at them. They make no impressions on the soldiers of the NVA. The quality of the writing is very poor and not good Vietnamese. The Americans should let the Vietnamese write them as they know how to put the story, or what you want said into poetry, the Vietnamese are a very poetic people. I know and all the men in my unit know the lines of a poem used by South Vietnam and we thought of it often. The best way to tell of good will is by a poem. The South Vietnamese poem that we remember is for our mother. It goes like this:
Since I have been away from you following my friends to Laos and then to Central Vietnam through the mountain areas, being sunburned by the sun in the coastal area, I have suffered all kinds of hardships.
The youth age similar to a blossom flower, due to the cost of peace we are not afraid of the difficulties.
During six months of day movement and night rest Ive worn out my boot soles and shirt collars by the cold weather
DIARY OF AN INFILTRATOR
This poem is also found in the December 1966 United States Mission in Vietnam (Saigon), 30-page booklet: Diary of an Infiltrator. All the entries in the diary are direct quotations in translation from the Vietnamese. Extracts from several hundred captured diaries were screened to produce this composite. Most of the diaries were taken in the Highlands and cover the period from July 1965 to August 1966.
I did not want to depict this leaflet because it is all text. However, we are mentioning dairies here and there were a whole series of JUSPAO leaflets that featured passages from the diaries of dozens of dead NVA and Viet Cong soldiers. I feel that I should show at least one of that series here. I will depict the back of the leaflet where the actual page from the dairy is reproduced. The front says in part:
COMMUNIST CADRES AND SOLDIER OF NORTH VIETNAM
Friends, read the lines of a North Vietnamese soldiers diary and you will understand the fate of your comrades-in-arms who have been wounded. The thin silhouettes of weak and sick men on the road back to the North were really a pitiful site.
The back of the leaflet basically gives the facts and says that this is an excerpt by Vu Cong Hoan who has a sweetheart named Tran Thi Kiem Hoan in Tu Ne Village who is a student. The dairy entry says in part:
I go up and down along the ravine and am very tired. I see batches and batches of skinny and weak men going from the South to the North, especially the disabled soldiers. How terrified and fed up with the war I feel I feel so very tired. I keep on sneezing and do not feel well at all. My mind is full of thoughts for my family and my darling. As I look at my darlings picture I miss her so much.
A soldier tells his wife in leaflet 4388:
Rice and food are abundant in South Vietnam but we havent eaten a grain of rice in months. It is very hard to have no rice and very little other food at all
Other entries are sadder. Leaflet 4399 has a dying soldier saying:
All I have left is 700 piasters, a Movado wrist watch and a Pilot fountain pen. You can have my American cigarette lighter, but in deference to the wishes of a dead man please send the rest to my son.
Korean War Leaflet 1118
What is particularly interesting about this Vietnam War leaflet is that the face of the woman is exactly the same as a leaflet printed by U.S. forces in the Korean War. I can hardly think of another case where the same image was used by U.S. forces in two wars. That leaflet, dated 26 October 1951 and coded 7009 was entitled Needless death. It targeted Chinese troops in Korea and depicts a dead soldier thinking of his mother. It was also produced in the Korean language coded 1118. Some of the text is:
Why must 1 be forced to die? If only I had acted earlier I could have escaped. When the Communists saw that I could no longer fight they left me to die alone. If my mother knew, how she would weep. I wonder how they will tell her. How sad she will be?
Perhaps my comrades will be wiser than I was if I could only tell them!
THERE IS NO NEED TO DIE GO OVER TO THE UN LINES EASCAPE, SAVE YOUR LIVES!
Leaflet 78T is bright red on the front and depicts happy scenes of life in North Vietnam. The back is blue and depicts a sad North Vietnamese soldier thinking of death and destruction in South Vietnam. This leaflet was dropped on troops coming down the Ho Chi Minh Trail. The text on the back explains that the poem printed on the leaflet was written by a North Vietnamese soldier to his mother, Mrs. Tran Thi Phan of Hai Duong. The soldier was killed in the battle of Duc Co and his soul is still blaming the Communist Party for sending him south to die. The poem is printed as a legacy and warning to other young men who have been sent south to die. The poem is very long at 40 lines. Note that the poem is identical to 2263 above. I quote some selected lines here:
A POEM TO MOTHER
(A North Vietnamese Youth Spills out his Heart)
From the day I left you, O mother, to follow my companions in this trip through Laos to Central Vietnam.
I have endured the hardships of climbing up the giant mountains, and marching through rain and shine.
Although at my young age life could have blossomed like a flower, enduring hardships and dangers, for several months I marched during the day and rested at night.
The bottoms of my shoes have worn out, and the cloth on my shoulders has worn thin and the cold slips in.
Often my hands trembled while laying a mine, because later I saw people blown up and blood sprayed around.
Whose blood was it?
It was the blood of our people, those like mother and me.
That night my eyes were filled with tears, and my sleep with nightmares.
Retired Lieutenant Colonel Dave Underhill of the 7th PSYOP Group told me about the use of poetry for psychological operations:
The Vietnamese loved poetry. We reproduced a poem written by an enemy soldier that was taken from his body on the field of battle. It was based on his experiences in the war and the fact that he had been deceived by the authorities. It was a very sad and sentimental poem.
When I was in Laos to write a strategic leaflet program for the American Embassy, a Central Intelligence Agency representative mentioned the leaflet. He said it was a very powerful leaflet and every prisoner taken could recite the entire poem from memory. He wanted to know who produced it. When I mentioned that our organization had produced it, he wanted to obtain the leaflet in quantity. I was able to immediately divert to him a shipment of several million copies that was destined for IV Corp, an area where there were few North Vietnamese regulars. The CIA representative was appreciative and impressed with our efficiency.
We produced several nostalgic poem leaflets for use at Tet in the 6x3 size for use throughout Vietnam and the Ho Chi Minh Trail area. My Vietnamese advisor (while I pulled a tour at the MACV PSYOP Directorate, Leaflet Development Section) helped develop poetry leaflets. He was Catholic, a former college professor, and had to flee North Vietnam when the French left. After US troop withdrawal we hired him and placed him in charge of leaflet development.
Note that this poem was considered so important that it appeared on several different leaflets in black and white and in color, and in various sizes such as 3 x 6-inches, and 5 x 7-inches.
A JUSPAO document dated 18 September 1969 is entitled Poem by North Vietnam Deserter. The document states that the poem was written by a Hoi Chanh who did not ask for money. The poem, written by Hoai Thanh was entitled Letter to my Comrade at Spring time. The letter says in part: I suggest that this be considered for use on radio, television, magazines, newspapers and leaflets. This, after all, is a nation of poets. The single most effective leaflet dropped in the past was the soldiers poem to his mother. [The writer might be describing the poem above]. This appears to be more of the same. A few lines from the six-stanza poem:
For I know that your heart is bleeding and your weeping soul longs for life at springtime.
Oh come dead liberation soldier, do not deny that which is most precious to you.
My heart aches as I write to you for we are both so far from our native land.
Together we came to face death on the battle field but it was for the benefit of just the few
What is amazing is that upon his capture, North Vietnamese Army 2nd Lieutenant Nguyen Van Thong, Leader of a Reconnaissance Platoon, mentioned American propaganda when interviewed by Military Intelligence. He said in part:
I have seen lots of the PSYOP leaflets but they are very poor and we laugh at them. They make no impression on the soldiers of the NVA...The quality of the writing is very poor and not good Vietnamese. The Americans should let the Vietnamese write them as they know how to put the story or what you want said into poetry; the Vietnamese are a very poetic people The best way to tell of good will is with a poem. All of the men in my unit knew the lines of a poem used in South Vietnam and we thought of it often. The poem that we remember is for our mother.
The poem of course was the one on 78T. The North Vietnamese apparently picked it up walking down the trail and found it so moving that they memorized it.
I looked through my files for an example of what Dave was talking about in his last paragraph and here is a Tet-themed poetry leaflet dropped along the Ho Chi Minh Trail. I note that some other poetry leaflets dropped over the Ho Chi Minh Trail about the same time are: T-42 (New Years Day); T-43 (Longing for the North); T-50 (Village Gate); T-52 (My Native Village) and T-53 (My Home). All were obviously produced to invoke nostalgia and homesickness.
Leaflet T-44 depicts a lonely wife and child watching other children play at a Tet celebration. Some of the text is:
I burn the incense and think of you
Spring returns and cites your merits
Father died in prison leaving mother sad
You left when you were only fourteen
How could you know what revolution is?
Taking advantage and speculating in politics
Merchants of slaves with black market prices
Caught in a trap which tightens the more you struggle
If you are mad then stand up and cry
I suffer to see our people as insensitive as stone
To give an example of how much Vietnamese loved poetry we need only look at a catalog of Viet Cong leaflets disseminated in 1962 and filed in a United States Information Service booklet entitled National Liberation Front Propaganda. A brief look at some of the enemy leaflets discloses: A poem aimed at a soldier away from home and family; a poem entitled A Mothers Words to her son in the army; Three poems taken from a collection called The Bright Road from the wife of a guerrilla to her husband; A book of poetry entitled Slash the Barbed Wire about Vietnamese trying to escape from government Strategic Hamlets; A poem entitled A Mothers Heart; A passionate poem that includes the words How inhumane is Diem and the United States, how tyrannically they betray the people, how miserable are the peasants and works; A poem from the wife of an ARVN asking him why he supports the wrong side; and a poem dealing with the cruelties of war entitled The Rice Field is the Reason for Existence. I could add many more, but this should give the reader an idea of the Viet Congs use of poetry in propaganda.
The simple fact is that many of the Vietnamese could not read. During the Vietnam War, numerous leaflets were prepared without text so that any finder could easily understand the message. The above leaflet is a case in point. It was prepared by JUSPAO about early 1967 and depicts the various forces helping South Vietnam on the front. We see the marching troops of The Republic of Korea, Australia, the United States, the Republic of Vietnam and New Zealand. The back of the leaflet depicts a helpless member of the Viet Cong being forced forward at gunpoint by China. These were simple images and any finder should have understood the message unless they did not recognize the flags and Communist symbols; and I am sure there were many such Vietnamese. In those cases, the leaflet images would have no meaning at all.
This leaflet was prepared by the 244th PSYOP Company in 1968. It was made for Viet Cong that could not read. On the front the VC are defeated in a battle and a badly wounded fighter returns to his base camp and finds that they have left without him. The back shows an alternative scenario. The Viet Cong fighter surrenders and receives immediate medical care.
This leaflet was one selected by the Department of Defense to be evaluated for effectiveness by a test group of about 1,757 Vietnamese civilians, Hoi Chanhs (former Viet Cong who had defected) and North Vietnamese and Viet Cong prisoners of war. The leaflets were judged as very effective, moderately effective or ineffective in a publication entitled The Effectiveness of U.S. PSYOPS Leaflets: A Scale for Pretesting published 7 January 1969. The former Viet Cong questioned about this leaflet found it very bad, counter-effective and unintelligible.
The Vietnam War
Ken Welch spent over seven years in Vietnam working first in Intelligence positions and later in the Phoenix Program. He explains the Vietnamese name of the program with some humor in Tiger Hound: How We Won the War & Lost the Country, Outskirts Press, Inc.:
The Phoenix Program was designed to neutralize the Viet Cong Infrastructure (VCI): the communist party members and cadre that recruited, proselytized, and attempted to form a shadow government to take over the legitimate government. Phoenix was an American term referring to the mythical bird that rose from the ashes; in this case, the name symbolized rising from the ashes of Tet 1968. There was no such bird in Vietnamese myths so the Vietnamese translation was Phung Hoang, which was somewhat relative in Chinese but, in Vietnamese, was a mythical bird of love and marriage. I wondered aloud. Are we eliminating love and marriage for the communists? They would certainly die out then.
Military Assistance Command
The Phung Hoang Advisor Handbook
The Phung Hoang Advisor Handbook adds:
In accordance with Article 4, the President of
in decree number 280-a/TT/SL, 1 July 1968, promulgated the Phung Hoang Program. The intent and aim of the program is to utilize existing civilian and military agencies in a systematic and coordinated effort to destroy the Viet Cong infrastructure throughout Vietnam . Vietnam
The U.S. military described Phoenix as operations against the Viet Cong infrastructure to include: the collection of intelligence; identifying their members; inducing them to abandon their allegiance to the Viet Cong and rally to the government; capturing or arresting them in order to bring them before province security committees or military courts for lawful sentencing; and as a final resort, the use of reasonable force should they resist capture or arrest where failure to use such force would result in the escape of the suspected Viet Cong member or would result in threat of serious bodily harm to a member or members of the capturing or arresting party.
The manner in which a suspect was to be investigated was very specific. For instance, once a suspect Viet Cong member was identified, two index cards were prepared in both alphabetic and village/hamlet files. Then a target folder was prepared which listed his habits, contacts, schedule, and modus operandi. The target folder required careful preparation and contained the VCI Target Personality Data Form and the Offender Dossier. This data was used as evidence when the Viet Cong member was brought to justice.
The program operated within a system of rules. Special laws (An Tri) allowed the arrest and prosecution of suspected communists, but only within the legal system. Moreover, to avoid abuses the law required three separate sources of evidence to convict any individual targeted for neutralization. Once identified, the individual was placed in one of three categories: A for leaders, B for those in key positions and C for rank and file members. If a suspected person was found guilty, he or she could be held in prison for 2 years, with renewable 2-year sentences totaling up to 6 years.
The Communists struck back and repeatedly emphasized attacking the governments
pacification program and specifically targeted
In a remarkable display of Chutzpah, the North Vietnamese, who had regularly used assassination as one of their tactics executing an estimated 36,725 village officials and South Vietnamese civil servants from 1957 to 1972 denounced Phoenix as an assassination program.
Was the program effective? Apparently it was. In
The Advisor handbook says in regard to publicity and communication:
Widespread popular understanding is essential to the success of the PHUNG HOANG Program. Various Government of Vietnam agencies that communicate with the population on a regular basis must be encouraged to provide meaningful publicity to the PHUNG HOANG Program The communications media available through the Vietnam Information Service and POLWAR agencies includes face-to-face persuasion, posters, handbills, newspapers, leaflets, radio, television and motion pictures PHUNG HOANG advisors are encouraged to coordinate with Province PSYOP advisors and Province PSYOP/POLWAR/Civic Action/ Vietnam Information Service Advisors to obtain publicity for the PHUNG HOANG Program .
Another special campaign was leaflets associated with the
Leaflet 7-514-68 is entitled THE DENOUNCING UNDERGROUND COMMUNIST SHEET. It is a four page printed document written in three languages that allows an informer to identify a Viet Cong member secretly. Some of the questions that the informer answers are:
I know the location of Viet Cong weapons, ammunition, explosives or documents.
I know the infiltration route for the transportation of Viet Cong weapons.
I suspect that I know of a relation of somebody in the Viet Cong cadre.
I know the location of the Viet Cong Economic team.
I know a place that sells good and medicines to the Viet Cong.
Speaking of the 7th PSYOP Battalion, According to the Operations Report Lessons Learned - Headquarters 7th Psychological Operations Battalion - period ending 30 April 1970, dated 11 May 1970:
An increase in rallier appeal leaflet requests and in the number of items developed in support of the Phoenix/Phung Hoang Program accounted for the increased support rendered by the battalion in March. During this reporting period, the 7th Battalion supported the Phoenix/Phung Hoang Program in its campaign to induce the local populace to report the location of the Viet Cong through the use of "wanted" posters.
The colored border on the standard poster design provided by 4th PSYOP Group, using the Vietnamese national colors to frame the photograph of the wanted Viet Cong infrastructure member was not used. It was determined after careful evaluation that persons living in rural areas, especially those who are illiterate, would recognize the national colors and gain the initial impression that the person pictured is a Government of Vietnam official or that he represents the Government of Vietnam. Posters with a colored border were used only in the production of general advertisements which called or the people to provide information on Viet Cong infrastructure. In one reported case, one of the posters led to the capture of a wanted criminal within 24 hours after it was posted.
I love that second paragraph. They were using a standard paper with the colors of the flag of the Republic of Vietnam; red and gold. Although the individual depicted was a terrorist, they worried that a farmer would see the colors and decide that the man was an official of some kind, a person to be respected. They saw the problem and solved it. Good thinking!
THE PHUNG HOANG PROGRAM PROTECTS THE
PEACE AND PROSPERITY OF THE PEOPLE
Participate in the Phung Hoang program in order to isolate the Communist cadre, to destroy their underground organization, and concurrently, to be able to avoid the terrorist activities caused by them.
Report any information of terrorist activity to the National Police or National Security Forces.
Your identity will be kept absolutely secret.
Some of the text on the back is:
The Government of
has launched the Phung Hoang Campaign in order to eliminate Communist leaders and their subordinates in local areas where you want to live an adequate and peaceful life. The Phung Hoang Campaign is an effort to seek and gather information that will lead us to those dangerous Viet Cong cadre... Vietnam
Leaflet 4-3-71 has the identical image and text on the front but a different message on the back. It says it part:
The Phung Hoang Campaign is designed for the benefit of the people. By participating in this campaign we will fulfill the following objectives:
Eliminate the underground Communist cadre. Destroy their organizations. Prevent Communist terrorism and acts of destruction. Help to restore peace and prosperity to the country
Participation in the Phuong Hoang campaign builds security for our hamlets.
The back is all text:
The Phuong Hoang campaign is aimed at neutralizing the entire Viet Cong infrastructure so that the people can get rid of Viet Cong terrorism and oppression. Therefore, people are encouraged to participate in this campaign, thus contributing to the building of peace and prosperity for themselves and their families.
Inform the National Police or other local security agencies of all Viet Cong activities. Your names will be kept absolutely secret.
Uncoded Phoenix Leaflet
This leaflet is all text on the front and back and bears no code. Because of the lack of code I thought this might be a South Vietnamese leaflet but the translator says the syntax seems to be more American in origin.
Dear Fellow Citizens
Since 1965, the Government of South Vietnam has tried to establish security, bring back a peaceful life, and at the same time improve the standard of living.
Even in the time of war the government has done its best to improve all aspects of society. The present improvements are: fixing the roads and bridges to make it easier to move around; providing farmers with high-yield rice seeds; water pumps; forming farmer banks...all are to improve the people's lives. More schools and health care stations are opening to educate and cure people.
In view of those accomplishments, what have the communists done for the people? They have kidnapped your children and taken them to the jungles; robbed your grain and money; dug up and mined the roads where you travel; and murdered village chiefs and their relatives. They invited and consorted with the Northern communists to ravage the villages and to cause bloodshed to the innocent. They are truly murderers!
You can help stop the blood-shedding of the innocent by being aware of the communists and reporting their activities to the government. The Viet Cong's infrastructure cadres have already placed northern communists in the villages. Remember the number of people who were murdered and killed when the communists took over in 1954. If the Viet Cong and the northern communists have the upper hand, how many thousands more people will be killed in the south? We must unite and resolve to defeat the barbaric and inhumane communists.
We must immediately report on the Viet Cong infrastructure that caused and is still the cause of damage in term of the lives and property of our people.
A Selection of Phoenix Leaflets and Documents
program was an effective means of creating informers and defectors. The US therefore prepared an intensive publicity campaign called the Popular Information Program in October 1969 where American and Vietnamese psywar teams crisscrossed the countryside, using radios, leaflets, posters, TV shows, movies, banners, and loudspeakers mounted on trucks and sampans to spread the word. Phoenix
Mr. Ba reads the
One of the more interesting PSYOP items was in the form of a comic book. It tells the story of a Mr. Ba who has Communist agents hiding in his
and decides to inform the authorities of their presence. The VC have taxed him, killed his friends and innocent civilians, and generally made life inconvenient by blowing up bridges and buildings. Mr. Ba reads posters offering rewards for the capture of the two VC and listens to the same offer on his radio. The village is then covered with aerial propaganda leaflets offering a reward for the two VC. Mr. Ba is convinced. He talks to the local authorities, the Communists are arrested and Ba is rewarded. The village is once again peaceful and all live happily ever after. villageof Phong Thanh
Major Marcus S. Welch mentions the comic in Irregular Pen and Limited Sword: PSYWAR, PSYOP, and MISO in Counterinsurgency, 2001-2002:
To augment the specific wanted posters, the general Phung Hoang comic book was created. Similar in concept to the Chieu Hoi Safe Conduct Pass, the Phung Hoang comic book provided the method for peasants and villagers to report information concerning Viet Cong activity, and how to do it anonymously. The comic book pictographically and textually conveyed the intent of Phung Hoang posters, leaflets, and broadcasts and how villagers could act on the information.
Lieutenant Winston Groom tells of his brief dealings with the Phoenix program as a member of the 245th PSYOP Company in
I was contacted by two civilians at Tuh Hoa during my stay at the MACV compound whom I assumed to be CIA agents. They came to me about some new project that I later discerned to be
. They had the names of individuals whom they knew or believed to be Viet Cong leaders in certain villages in the province. They thought it would be a good idea to print leaflets or posters listing these people, naming them and their villages. As they were caught or eliminated we would cross off that person's name on the leaflet. I can't recall exactly what symbols we used after 40 years, but I think if they guerrilla was captured; a small caricature of a man being led away in chains was placed over his name. If he was killed his name was covered by a skull and crossbones. Phoenix
They brought me Vietnamese-language hand-written examples of the leaflets they desired showing the names of the supposed Viet Cong killed and captured and I would order the leaflets adding the man in chains or the skull and crossbones and we would drop them wherever appropriate. The object was to let the people know that if they were Viet Cong, there was no place to hide from us, and to make the other villagers think twice about becoming or harboring Viet Cong. How well it worked I can't say. But in my opinion, it ought to have been very effective. My own role in this was just getting the leaflets printed and calling in the drops, but there was something satisfying about it, kind of like you were a spy.
Chandlermentions similar operations in War of Ideas; The U.S. Propaganda Campaign in Vietnam: Phoenix
Wanted posters were put up (with photographs whenever possible) Blacklists were posted on village bulletin boards with an X crossed over the names of those eliminated to show the campaigns progress and the steady depletion of the of the insurgent ranks.
The Australian forces in
Vietnamhad a program similar to , but Derrill de Heer, formerly of the 1st Psychological Operations Unit, is quick to point out that there were some major differences. He mentions Acorn operations and says that it was a radio code word for Intelligence personnel. They used Foxhound for infantry and Litterbug for PSYOP personnel. De Heer says in part: Phoenix
Acorn operations were about identifying the underground enemy and convening operations that amounted to snatch and grab raids to apprehend them. They were then interrogated and handed over to the appropriate authority.
The Vietnamese Communist Infrastructure (VCI) operated against political targets and performed executions and political coercion by means of extortion, kidnapping and other illegal means. The only way to operate against them was by collecting high value intelligence enabling them to be seized in their homes and prosecuted before a court and having them jailed.
The Australians obtained information from prisoners of war, Hoi Chanhs, captured documents and other Free World intelligence agencies. Acorn operations took at least six weeks to prepare and involved an aerial reconnaissance by the group commanders a day or two prior to the operation being conducted.
The Australian Acorn intelligence operations against the VCI were organized locally by the 1st Australian Task Force and were not part of the
Republicof Vietnam Phuong Hoanganti-infrastructure or the U.S. operations. An example is operation number 17 where twenty six known VCI or active supporters were detained in forty minutes using a total of forty four personnel and a protection party. In the seventy days from 17 September to 27 November 1970 a total of eighty Viet Cong (VC) or Viet Cong Infrastructure (VCI) or Viet Cong Suppliers (VCS) personnel were taken into custody by the unit. Phoenix
is Concerned Nam
Whenever I see a leaflet with an interesting theme I add it to our story of the PSYOP of the Vietnam War. The
produced a number of leaflets defending the defoliation program to the Vietnamese people and explaining how much safer they would be once the local flora was dead and gone. We now know what a horror Agent Orange was and that thousands of Americans, and perhaps millions of Vietnamese were harmed by it. The result is still seen today as the children and grandchildren of those who came in contact with the defoliants continue to suffer various medical maladies. This leaflet depicts four cartoons on the front and three on the back. The story starts with young United States realizing that the Viet Cong hide in thick bushes. He tries to avoid them by going home by boat, but again, Viet Cong in bushes along the canal rob him and kill his cousin. The government then defoliates the land and all live happily ever-after. Some of the text is: Nam
IS CONCERNED ABOUT THE DEFOLIATION CHEMICALS NAM
The defoliation chemical is used for the purpose of drying trees and striping off their leaves. It does not harm human beings, animals, land or water at all.
One of the men spraying the chemical tells him:
Look at me. Dont I look strong and healthy. Because of my work I have to breathe the defoliation chemical daily; and as you can see, I am not a sick man
If by misfortune, your crops are damaged by the defoliation chemical, the government will indemnify you...
An American PSYOP policy statement adds:
PSYOP personnel should be prepared to counter VC and VC-inspired allegations that herbicides in the RVN are poisonous and bring harm to humans and animals that come in contact with them.
Our output should make the point that defoliants used in RVN are non-poisonous; even food and water affected by the spray can be consumed without danger.
A Viet Cong Ambush
Another leaflet depicts Viet Cong ambushing boats in a narrow canal on one side and boats sailing smoothly on the other. Some of the text is:
BEFORE THE USE OF DEFOLIATION CHEMICALS, WHEN TREES AND BUSHES ALONG THE CANAL GREW WILD
The Viet Cong took advantage of the thick bushes to terrorize, to kill and plunder our countrymen It is difficult for the Army to control and sweep away the Viet Cong.
AFTER THE USE OF DEFOLIATION CHEMICALS, WHEN TREES AND BUSHES ALONG THE CANAL HAVE BEEN DEFOLIATED
The Viet Cong have nowhere to take shelter and plunder, terrorize or kill our countrymen The Army can easily eliminate the Viet Cong in order to bring security to our relatives and friends.
Another all-text leaflet says in part:
Up to now, the Viet Cong often took advantage of the bushes to hide themselves in order to ambush and attack buses, or to organize murders and terrorize people. In some localities they even mine the roads killing many innocent countrymen...The Government is using some special chemicals to defoliate thick trees and bushes where the Viet Cong hide This chemical dries out trees and bushes in the areas sprayed only, and will not cause any damage to the people or animals. Even if this chemical sticks to your body or is mixed with your food and drink, your life will not be endangered Do not listen to the Viet Cong distorting propaganda .
It is interesting to note that like so many other factors of the Vietnam War, the American military apparently borrowed the concept of defoliants like Agent Orange from the British Emergency in
Malaya. A secret British Government Memorandum by the Secretary of State for the Colonies dated 21 December 1951 says in part:
It is agreed on all hands that the risks of ambush by bandits can be greatly reduced by defoliation of roadside jungle. A certain amount of this is already being done by hand but the process is slow and costly and the vegetation quickly grows again. Chemical defoliation would, it is believed, be much more effective. Experiments on a small scale have been carried out using two recently discovered hormone weed killers (2-4-D and 2-4-5-T) with Sodium trichloracetate in various combinations. Tests began on the 17 September 1951, by means of hand sprays, and within ten days the foliage was dead
Almost three decades later, On 11 March 1979, the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) took unprecedented steps against the chemical. In the first such emergency ban ever, the EPA ordered the immediate halt to most uses of the herbicide 2-4-5-T which contains Dioxin. U. S.
For all the talk about the perils of Agent Orange to the VC in the bush, I was surprised to find a report of the 1967 interrogation of North Vietnamese Army Company commander Nguyen Luu Thanh. He stated that he always received a one-hour warning before any aircraft were sent to his area on defoliation missions. This indicates that their intelligence or spies among the Vietnamese officers were very good. The VC soldiers covered their eyes with a nylon cloth. They breathed through a canvas or gauze cloth impregnated with chemicals and charcoal. Thanh said that these protective items were completely effective and men using them suffered no ill-effects. The VC seemed to have no fear of the defoliation chemicals.
Of course, it should be pointed out that this interview occurred in 1967 and although Thanh thought he was fully protected, many of the symptoms of Agent Orange and other defoliant poisons would not show up for another 10 or 20 years.
The Assassination of Diem
Ngo Dinh Diem, a Catholic Vietnamese nationalist, returned from exile in the
United Statesto lead the Government of Vietnamwith support in 1954. U.S.
Considering that the United States supported President Ngo Dinh Diem in the early days of the war as a staunch anti-Communist, it is surprising that when a group of Vietnam generals brought up the subject of his overthrow at a later time the Americans appear to have complied. Allegedly he was not to be harmed, just to be removed from office and replaced.
A first military coup against Diem occurred in November 1960. In February 1962, disgruntled air force pilots bombed the presidential palace in hopes of killing Diem, but he survived that attempt too. The third and successful overthrow attempt occurred on 1 November 1963 and Diem was killed the following day. Although Diem had been offered exile from
, he was murdered in the back of an armored personnel carrier after being captured. According to Aherns CIA report: Vietnam
The ignominious demise of Diem and Nhu shocked and dismayed President Kennedy, who according to Maxwell Taylor's account leaped to his feet and rushed from the meeting which Michael Forrestal had interrupted to announce their deaths Headquarters had been warned of the high risk that Diem would not survive a military coup. But the event shocked
, to the extent that Smith thought Headquarters' reaction almost hysterical Dismay at the brutal treatment of Diem and Nhu generated a panicky concern for the safety of the Nhu children. President Kennedy enjoined McCone to ensure their safe conduct to their mother, then in Washington Europe.
Ho Chi Minh reportedly said:
I can scarcely believe the Americans would be so stupid.
One might think that as a valued friend of the Americans, he would have been treated kindly in the psychological operations that occurred after his death. Nothing could be further from the truth. He was insulted and reviled in a series of leaflets and one would think he had been a monster. A few of the early JUSPAO leaflets that mention Diem are; SP-40, SP-42, SP-52, SP-53, SP-55, SP-57, SP-58, SP-62 and SP-71.
In the various leaflets we see comments like:
After living for years under the cruel, dictatorial and feudal rule of the Ngo family, the people of
South Vietnamand the Army of rose up on 1 November 1963 and overthrew the rotten regime. Vietnam
This glorious victory has put an end to a brutal and inefficient dictatorship.
Freedom has now been recovered. The totalitarian regime of Ngo Dinh Diem has been toppled.
Secret agents loyal to the Ngo family harassed those who complained about the regime The Nhu-Diem clique plotted to sell our country to the Communists.
Under the despotic, corrupt and cruel dictatorship of Ngo Dinh Diem and his clan, sufferings were ignored and you were oppressed and plundered without pity.
All of the leaflets were text-only except for SP-71 that was printed with four photographs showing all the gifts and rewards that were available to the Vietnamese under the new Revolutionary Government. The leaflet depicts; a school girl with textbooks given as gifts, tools offered by the Americans to workers in the hamlets, textbooks supplied to a group of children at a newly built school, and writing books given to students in a new life hamlet. Some of the text is:
At this time, the Military revolutionary Council and the Provincial Government are anxious about the rural life, particularly, the living conditions in the New Life Hamlets
All these gifts are a symbol of the government of the
s solicitude. Republicof Vietnam
JUSPAO was quick to prepare leaflets depicting some of the plotters that led the movement to oust Diem. Leaflets SP-65 and SP-67 both depict General Duong van Minh and Prime Minister Nguyen Ngoc. Some of the text is:
General Duong van Minh is a man of the people. He has suffered much at the hands of evil people and believes strongly in justice for all the people. He is a kindly man and is beloved by all that know him.
Nguyen Ngoc is an ardent Buddhist and has nine children and a great interest in an overall national plan for the development of the Vietnamese economy.
On 1 November 1963, a group of patriotic Vietnamese military officers and civilians staged a revolution and overthrew the government of the Ngo family. To date the new government has:
Liberated from prison all illegally held.
Brought new freedoms to the people
Is going to conquer poverty, ignorance, stagnation and despair
The new government is worthy of the support of loyal Vietnamese. Prepare to be part of this new and better life in Vietnam. Cooperate with the new government.
Song Sheet 1827
Another special theme was song sheets. The Vietnamese must have loved to sing because there were dozens of different leaflets prepared and disseminated that gave the words and music to pro-Government patriotic songs. I had my choice of a wide variety to illustrate, but chose the fiercely patriotic
. This 8 x 10-inch leaflet was developed in April 1967 and distributed to the people to motivate them to support their Government. Some of the text is: Viet Nam
Heard since our cradle
Viet-Nam two words
Formed on our lips;
, our motherland; Viet Nam
Viet Nam, Viet Nam
A peoples name;
Viet-Nam the two words
Two final words of a dying man
As I stated above, there were numerous propaganda song sheets prepared by JUSPAO to be issued to the Vietnamese for motivational purposes. Some of those songs are:
JUSPAO Code Number, Song Title and Date of Production:
1685 Marching Song of the Revolution Development Cadre January 1967
1686 It is Better to Sing Often than Well January 1967
1687 Let us Put on Black Coats January 1967
1688 Bowl of Rice, Bowl of Sweat, Bowl of Blood January 1967
1913 A Cadres Love July 1967
1914 Patriotic Folksong July 1967
1915 Self Defense Militia July 1967
1971 Republic of Vietnam National Anthem August 1967
2352 Countryside Upheaval December 1967
2363 Months and Years of Waiting January 1968
2364 Spring Without You January 1968
The 4th PSYOP Group prepared a rather odd group of leaflets in 1969 and 1970. In each they used an image that was very clumsily drawn, almost like finger paint with a lot of black and green color. It is only after reading the military explanation sheet that you can figure out what the image represents. For instance, 4-82-69 appears to be a bunch of blobs but we are told it is a bouquet of roses. 4-87-69 is entitled Night sky with moon and Tree and field so apparently that green glob is the sky and a landscape. The text makes no mention of the images so apparently it was thought that the Vietnamese would recognize them. We see the same sort of drawings (perhaps from the same artist) a year later in 1970. Leaflet 4-11-70 depicts a green and black mass that is identified as "Unmarked graves, and 4-13-70 shows a green blob that is identified as Flowering plants.
Some of the text of 4-87-69 is:
It is time for you to carefully ponder this thought: there is no reason for you to die in a conflict that sooner or later will be resolved at a conference table. Now is the time for you to think about your own and your familys future life. You should follow the good example of your cadre and your comrades. Return to the National Just Cause; you will have the chance to rebuild your life again in a generous nation where love replaces hate.
One of the stranger themes used during the war was superstition. In another article we mention the use of the sounds of funeral marches and ghosts to frighten the enemy. There were also a series of four leaflets that claimed to quote a Vietnamese philosopher and mystic that forecast the defeat of the North. During WWII, both the Allies and the Axis used similar themes quoting Nostradamus and various astrologers.
Leaflet 4-19-70 depicts a pair of eyes and was meant to reinforce the Viet Congs fear of the unknown. See 4-124-69 below.
Leaflet 4-22-70 depicts an incense burner near an open book. The text attempts to convince the Viet Cong to return home by quoting the prophecies of Trang Trinh. Some of the text is:
God did not trust Ho Chi Minh with founding a nation
Alas, the destiny of the country has not yet come true. The south gate is not shut, but the north gate (to China) is opened. The people are cheering in the daytime but crying at night
Leaflet 4-23-69 depicts a sign of the zodiac and is entitled THE FUTURE OF THIS WAR HAS BEEN DECIDED! Some of the text is:
Trang Trinh gained supernatural power after he received a book from a great Chinese man Trang Trinhs prophecy states that peace will begin to return to our people in the year 1970.
Leaflet 4-24-70 depicts a Ying-Yang (sign of harmony between the positive and negative) symbol. The title is You cannot go against destiny. Some of Trang Trinhs prophecies appear once again:
Alas, there is too much confusion in this mundane business.
When will the road from North to South be cleared?
He hides himself in the caves (tomb), while Mao sees white (ages).
The whales (warships) float in the bloody sea.
Leaflet 4-29-70 is entitled THE COMMUNISTS CANNOT CHANGE DESTINY. Some of the text is:
This poem is one of hundreds of prophecies made by Trang Trinh A remarkable individual from the North who has been well-known for over 400 years In this poem he said that after the death of Ho Chi Minh the Northern regime would collapse
Leaflet 4-39-70 is entitled TRANG TRINHS PROHECIES FORETOLD THE FUTURE OF
. Some of the text is: VIETNAM
In the 16th century the prophecies of Trang Trinh were respected by the Kings and his lords. The following of his prophecies have been fulfilled:
The defeat of the French in 1954. The death of Ho Chi Minh in 1969. The North has been divided internally since Hos death and will fall
Leaflet 4-40-70 depicts a sign of harmony between the negative and the positive and repeats the text of leaflet 4-29-70.
I like this leaflet a lot. In Iraq and Afghanistan the U.S. prepared leaflets using the same general image which they called the Evil Eye. In reality it was just telling the enemy guerrillas that they were being watched by aircraft and satellite, but it was known that some Muslims feared the Evil Eye and the leaflet might also work on that emotional and superstitious level. This leaflet was aimed at the North Vietnamese Army troops coming down the Ho Chi Minh Trail to fight the armed forces of the Republic of Vietnam. This leaflet is coded from the 4th PSYOP Group but we know it was actually printed for them by the 7th PSYOP Group on Okinawa. The text on the front is:
THE DEEP JUNGLE IS WATCHING YOU!
The text on the back is:
THE FACE OF THE GREEN JUNGLE IS WATCHING YOU.
To friends in the rank and file of the North Vietnamese troops.
In the dark thick jungle, the jungle eyes are watching you. You were watched since your first steps down your infiltration path. Your prayers became hopeless. No place is so impenetrable that you can hide in it. The green jungle eyes are watching you.
Heaven's net casts wide. Though its meshes are coarse, nothing slips through. There will be more bombs and artillery rounds coming to you.
Go back! Return to the North while you still can!
Note: The "Heaven's net" quotation is from Lao Tsu's Tao Te Ching, chapter 73.
One Vietnamese whose grandfather had been a Viet Cong guerrilla told me:
My grandpa told me that he felt much safer being in the jungle. At least the jungle could hide them from bombardments, except from the B-52s. Talking about superstition, he told me that he often hoped if the jungle Gods had to choose who lived or died, they would choose to protect the locals rather than those strange white foreigners. Thus the proverb: JUNGLE COVERS US, JUNGLE SURROUNDS THE ENEMIES.
Another Vietnamese replied:
I am not sure that the Laotian and Cambodian jungle Gods would protect either side in the war, since both were foreign to the land. Remember, the Ho Chi Minh Trail lies mainly in Laos and Cambodia.
Testing Various Red Eyes for the Leaflet
I thought the reader might be interested in the way the leaflet was prepared. After the background was finished, they wanted to add some color to the watching eyes. They made a half dozen different eyes that were printed separately and they placed them over the leaflet so they could be flipped back and forth to see how they looked. Some looked benign, others looked positively evil. I believe this is the one they finally used.
The End of the American Presence Nears
As the Americans prepared to pull out of
Vietnamin 1973 the propaganda leaflets gradually changed in an attempt to demoralize the Government of and its troops in the south. Two leaflets are perfect examples of this campaign. North Vietnam
Leaflet 4488 depicts President Richard Nixon shaking hands with Mao Tse-tung. This image was meant to show the North Vietnamese that the
United States of Americaand the Peoples Republic of Chinawere now friends and all aid to would be halted. Of course, this was not true and the aid continued to flow into North Vietnam . The text on the front of the leaflet is: North Vietnam
AN HISTORIC MEETING
Chinese Communist Chairman Mao Tse-tung receives U.S. President Nixon in
Peking. The two Chiefs of State exchange a friendly handshake at the meeting in Maos palace on 21 February 1972.
As a propagandist you sometimes wonder if any of these leaflets prepared with such enthusiasm are read by the enemy. In Stuart A. Herringtons Stalking the Viet Cong Inside Operation Phoenix: A Personal account, Ballantine Books, NY, the author is present at an interrogation of a North Vietnamese prisoner-of-war named Do van Lanh from the 271st Independent Regiment. The POW asks if he may ask a question. He is told to proceed. He says:
Has President Nixon gone to Moscow yet?
It is apparent that Combatant Do van Lahn has read a leaflet and remembered the text.
This is a tiny leaflet, just 2 x 6-inches in size. It is all text and I never had any interest in adding it to the article. But while filing today I read some of the text and that changed my mind. In this leaflet President Nixon drops the hammer. He is clearly annoyed with North Vietnam and has escalated the war to try and force them to the peace table. The text is extremely long so I will just add a few lines of the more threatening lines:
PEOPLE OF NORTH VIETNAM
On 8 May 1972, President Nixon announced that he will take the following actions against the aggression of North Vietnam toward the Republic of Vietnam:
All the entrances to North Vietnam ports will be mined to prevent incoming ships and outgoing North Vietnamese naval forces.
North Vietnamese supply lines, rails and highways will be cut off.
All Naval and Air strikes on North Vietnamese military installations will continue.
The leaflet goes on to state that when all U.S. prisoners-of-war are returned and there is a viable ceasefire in place the U.S. military actions will be halted, and U.S. troops will be brought home.
At the same time that
was using diplomacy, it wanted to be sure that the North Vietnamese did not think that these maneuvers were a sign of weakness. As a result, several leaflets were prepared that once again stressed the military strength of the America . An example of what might be construed as a carrot and stick is leaflet 4503. It depicts an American aircraft carrier and says in part: United States
One of several
United StatesAircraft Carriers in the Gulfof Tonkinwith the mission of interdicting supplies destined for the North Vietnamese Army forces in . South Vietnam
The back is all text and says in part:
The President of the
announced in his 8 May 1972 speech that military actions would cease when the following conditions are met: United States
- All American prisoners of war must be returned.
- An agreement by
North Vietnamto an internationally supervised ceasefire throughout Indochina.
This May 1972 leaflet features a portrait of President Richard Nixon and his promise never to desert the Republic of Vietnam. Unfortunately, that was a promise that was not kept. Nixon said in part:
the United States will never abandon the 17 million South Vietnamese people to Communism and terror...
Richard Nixon is depicted with Leonid Brezhnev on leaflet 4558. Once again it is implied that the
United Statesand the Soviet Union are now friends and aid will no longer be sent to . Some of the text is: North Vietnam
Soviet Communist Party Secretary Leonid Brezhnev drinks a toast to U.S. President Richard Nixon after signing the agreement on Strategic Weapons Limitation on 26 May 1972
In later leaflets Nixon swears that the United States will never desert Vietnam, and after the bombing of the North and their agreement to talks the Allies print dozens of leaflets telling the Viet Cong that the war is about to end and peace will reign once again.
This leaflet depicts young North Vietnamese men being prepared to go to war. Some of the text on the front is:
NORTH VIETNAMS FINEST YOUNG MEN
On 1 April 1972, The Lao Dong leadership of North Vietnam directed an invasion by its army into the Republic of Vietnam. It sent into action the finest men North Vietnam had to offer In the first six weeks since 1 April 1972, over 20,000 North Vietnamese soldiers have been killed and an unknown number have been wounded.
The real reason I added this leaflet was because of a quote by General Giap on the back. The United States always wanted to be truthful in its leaflets because that was the way you gained credibility with the target audience. I believe the Americans wanted to drive the North Vietnamese to the peace table so used these published comments. However, in this case there seems to be some doubt. Some of the quoted statements are:
General Vo Nguyen Giap, the new North Vietnamese Defense Minister said: Every minute, hundreds of thousands of people die all over the world. The life or death of a hundred, a thousand, or tens of thousands of human beings, even if they are our own compatriots, really represents very little.
When asked in 1968 if he thought Allied claims of 650,000 NVA killed since 1961 were correct, he said Thats about right. Since that interview, over 150,000 additional NVA and Viet Cong troops have been killed .
A Vietnamese told me about the two statements above:
The first quote was not his and he denied having said that to Jules Roy, but Oriana Fallaci got it wrong and included it in the prelude to her interview with General Giap.
The second was his response to Fallaci's question about half a million losses claimed by MACV, to which the General responded in French "C'est exact," which can be translated as That's correct. There was some debate whether he meant That's correct that the NLF lost half a million or That's correct that the MACV claimed the NLF had lost half a million.
The Fallaci interview was never officially authorized as he thought it was an off-the-record chat between him and the delegates of Italian left-wing women and not an interview by Fallaci the journalist.
This leaflet was prepared in November 1972 and is one of the last to depict President Nixon because the United States was in the process of pulling out of Vietnam. In four months the American troops will be gone. The leaflet tells of Nixons reelection on the front so if the North Vietnamese believed he would be defeated and a more Liberal President elected, they were certainly disappointed. The text is very long on both sides so I just translate some selected portions:
President Nixon Reelected
President Richard M. Nixon has been reelected President of the United States for another four-year term. He received over 61% of the votes cast, while his opponent, Senator George McGovern received about 37% of the votes The question of how to terminate the war in Indochina was an issue in the minds of American voters. Their overwhelming expression of confidence in Mr. Nixon shows strong endorsement of his policies including support for U.S negotiations with North Vietnam which he urged during the election campaign .
Current Event Leaflet 4615
As the United States entered the year 1973 and became more determined to force the North into peace talks and get out of Vietnam, the leaflets became more repetitious. We find the same general message over and over again and all the leaflets discussed what would happen after the peace papers were signed. Some attempts were made to build the morale of the South and lower that of the North, but the majority of the leaflets were simply talk about postwar Vietnam. To give an example, there were dozens of what I might call CURRENT EVENT leaflets. They are all text and usually just a line or two. Some examples are:
4610 - Nixon reelected
4612 - Nixon goes to China
4613 - North and South Korea talks
4614 - Japan and China establish relations
4615 - Nixon visits the Soviet Union
The text on leaflet 4615 is:
President Nixons visit to the USSR in May 1972 is just one of many stops taking place during this era of friendly negotiations
There were also dozens with the title HOME BEFORE TET, HOME BY SPRING and HOME BY TET. They are interesting because they kind of mirror WWII leaflets where the Germans sarcastically talked about the Americans being home by Christmas. Dozens more had the title CEASEFIRE and talked about life after the shooting ceased. I should add that by this time the leaflets were mostly being printed by the 7th PSYOP Group on Okinawa.
In late 1972, as the Allies and the North Vietnamese began to talk, a major propaganda campaign was created to inform the people of the north of the peace talks. One of the earliest leaflets using this theme is 4583. One entire group all printed with a green vignette run from 4587 to 4591. In all, there are several dozen leaflets with the theme of informing the people of
. We illustrate leaflet 4588 dropped on 8 November 1972. North Vietnam
One side depicts a water buffalo and text:
Within 60-days of the signing of the peace agreement, all American forces will be withdrawn from
. North Vietnamese soldiers should be home long before the Tet Quy Suu (The Year of the Vietnam ). This will be the happiest Tet in memory. Buffalo
The other side bears a poem and text:
In my village there is rice and mulberry.
There are flocks of white storks and flirting words.
There is a banyan tree and a temple roof.
There are flocks of pretty, graceful country girls.
In the autumn there are village festivals.
In the spring crowds of children play with swings.
The wind whistles a kite-flute song.
Soothing the soul of the Shepherd boy on the dyke.
Long before spring and well in time for Tet Quy Suu you should be home with your loved ones. Within 60-days of the signing of the cease-fire agreement, all American forces will be withdrawn from
. The North Vietnamese soldiers can return home. Vietnam
Leaflet 4694 is the last leaflet in my collection. It is dated 20 January 1973, just 68 days before the last Americans leave
. The Government of Vietnam believes that peace is at hand and says so in this leaflet: Vietnam
WAR IS OVER VIETNAM
North Vietnamand the have signed a cease-fire agreement. The fighting in United States has stopped. All Vietnam U.S.and Korean forces are leaving . Because there is peace, North Vietnamese soldiers should leave South Vietnam South Vietnam, Laos, and . All North Vietnamese soldiers should be home in Cambodia to enjoy spring time. North Vietnam
SOON YOU WILL SEE YOUR FAMILY
The cease-fire has come. You do not have to fight anymore. You can rejoin your family in
to enjoy spring time. Think how wonderful to be with your family once again. North Vietnam
In reality, the Communists used the peace talks to rebuild and reinforce their troops and invaded and conquered the South in the spring of 1975. The promise of assistance from the
United Statesin the form of economic aid and the promise that forces would return if there was aggression from the north did not materialize. The financial support promised was severely reduced by the United States Congress, as was the military equipment. The South Vietnamese government had to reduce the numbers in the military and government officials as they were unable to pay all the soldiers and public servants. US
Lewis Sorley mentions the betrayal in A Better War: The Unexamined Victories and the Final Tragedy of America's Last Years in Vietnam, Harcourt Brace and Co.,
, 1999. Sorley says that the Florida had defeated the Viet Cong in the field, returned control of most of the population to the South Vietnamese, and left the South Vietnamese armed forces able to continue the war on its own. Victory only required United States to provide the South with adequate supplies and intelligence, and bomb the North if they violated peace agreements. However, at the very time that the North was receiving arms supplied by America Chinaand , the South had its supply of weapons and ammunition cut. Sorley points out that Nixon and Kissinger and the American political leadership are to blame for the loss of the South. Russia
Richard Nixon wrote in a letter to South Vietnamese President Nguyen Van Thieu on 5 January 1973:
You have my assurance of continued assistance in the post-settlement period that we will respond with full force should the settlement be violated by North Vietnam.
But, Nixon and Kissinger were in the process of making a deal with the Communists that allowed the North to keep 160,000 of its forces in South at a time when the American presence was down to 27,000 troops. When Thieu balked at the secret agreement he was threatened and black-mailed by Nixon. Henry Kissinger quotes a Nixon letter to Thieu in The White House Years.
I have therefore irrevocably decided to proceed to initial the Agreement on January 23, 1973 and to sign it on January 27, 1973 in
. I will do so, if necessary, alone. In that case I shall have to explain publicly that your Government obstructs peace. The result will be an inevitable and immediate termination of Paris economic and military assistance which cannot be forestalled by a change of personnel in your government. I hope, however, that after all our two countries have shared and suffered together in conflict, we will stay together to preserve peace and reap its benefits. U.S.
Once it became clear that the
United Stateswould not fulfill its promises to the in 1975, Thieu wrote back to Nixon: Republicof Vietnam
If the Americans do not want to support us anymore, let them go, get out! Let them forget their humanitarian promises!
It appears that Nixon and Kissinger might have given the North the OK to attack South Vietnam once the U.S. was gone for a decent interval. Max Boot says in The Road Not Taken: Edward Lansdale and the American Tragedy in Vietnam:
Thus was born what became known as the decent interval strategy, with Nixon and Kissinger signaling to North Vietnam and its patrons in Moscow and Beijing that Washington wanted a face-saving way out of the conflict regardless of the consequences for Americas allies in Saigon. As Kissinger explained to Premier Zhou Enlai of China on 9 July 1971, If the [South Vietnamese] government is as unpopular as you seem to think, then the quicker our forces are withdrawn, the quicker it will be overthrown. And if it is overthrown after we withdraw, we will not intervene. Zhou inquired what time period would suffice between the American withdrawal and the Communist conquest of South Vietnam. Kissingers answer: Say eighteen months. The existence of the KissingerLe Duc Tho talks remained confidential until January 1972, when Nixon announced that they were going on, but even then the extent of the American concessions was not revealed.
United Stateswas not alone in helping the fight for its independence. Five other nations also sent troops; Republicof Vietnam Australia, New Zealand, Korea, Thailandand the . Philippines formed its own psychological operations unit for the first time since World War II. The 1st Psychological Operations Unit was formed as a divisional unit and allocated for duty with the 1st Australian Task Force in Phuoc Tuy province in the far southeast of Australia in the III Corps military area. Among the members were printers, photographers, intelligence personnel and other specialists. The Australian unit received aid and advice from U. S. Advisory Team 89 based in Ba Ria, Vietnam . The unit printed about 130 different leaflets, most coded with the letters ATF, though some leaflets are found without the "ATF" or with no number at all. Phuoc Tuy Province
We mention intelligence a dozen times in this article. Douglas Pike spent fifteen years in
. He was one of a small group of Vietnam Hanoiwatchers who has said that the United Statesnever really used its intelligence apparatus to learn what was going on in . He calls the American efforts modest, parochial and less than adequate. He says that even with 450,000 American servicemen in North Vietnam Vietnamthe watchers never numbered more than a dozen. They argued amongst themselves about whether Ho Chi Minh was a Communist or a nationalist. They argued about who was in charge between the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong. They debated if the Soviets or the Chinese where in a position of greater influence. Pike points out the difference between WWII and Hanoi . In the former there were hundreds, perhaps thousands of individuals assigned to knowing every aspect of the enemy. He suspects the reason so little was done during the Vietnam War was the belief that American firepower was so great that it really did not matter what the North Vietnamese did. They were irrelevant. They could be bombed back to the Stone Age, so why bother learning their plans and intentions? He does not use the word but he implies a certain "arrogance" at the highest level of government. Vietnam
Down at the tactical level where the rubber meets the road the military was very involved in intelligence activities. Some comments from a high-placed American Army intelligence agent:
The very sensitive intelligence files at [deleted] were very detailed about enemy military and civilian personnel, to include the southerners' families (if they had them) and their addresses and their names. Lesser detailed collateral intelligence versions were at [deleted]. There were more details available to
agents within the RVN National Police files. We could and did combine our files with the Vietnamese and have very detailed information about many of the southern communists so we could have air or ground dropped leaflets and/or fake documents that sent them home to check on their families. Very few sensitive reports went above Colonel level and never back to U.S. and/or DC unless someone requested them or someone else (CIA, etc.) sent them back for their own files. The Australians and New Zealanders worked very closely with us from collateral to very sensitive intelligence operations and the gathering of the intelligence too. It was a pleasure to work with them, and to supply them with reports from my [deleted] and [deleted] files Hawaii
THE PSYOP MASTERS
We mention General Edward Lansdale as a special advisor to Director Barry Zorthian in the section on JUSPAO at the beginning of this story. Colonel (later General) Edward Lansdale (USAF) is mentioned in The Vietnam Experience - Passing the Torch, Boston Publishing Company, MA, 1981. He was apparently the master of "Dirty tricks." Lansdale had served with the Office of Strategic Services in WWII. In the 1950s, Lansdale was transferred to the Philippines-based Joint United States Military Assistance Group (JUSMAG), to advise the intelligence services of the Armed Forces of the Philippines that were then faced with a serious threat to national security posed by the Communist Hukbong Mapagpalaya ng Bayan, (People's Liberation Army). While involved in the campaign against the HUKs, Lansdale helped create an ingenious military and intelligence operation that utilized a local and much feared legend: that of the terrifying Asuang Vampire. He said:
To the superstitious the HUK battleground was a haunted place filled with ghosts and eerie creatures. A combat psywar squad was brought in. It planted stories among town residents of an Asuang living on the hill where the HUKs were based. Two nights later, after giving the stories time to make their way up to the hill camp, the psywar squad set up an ambush along the trail used by the HUKs. When a HUK patrol came along the trail, the ambushers silently snatched the last man of the patrol, their move unseen in the dark night. They punctured his neck with two holes, vampire-fashion, held the body up by the heels, drained it of blood, and put the corpse back on the trail. When the HUKs returned to look for the missing man and found their bloodless comrade, every member of the patrol believed that the Asuang had go to him and that one of them would be next if they remained on that hill. When daylight came, the whole HUK squadron moved out of the vicinity.
A 1954 Operation Freedom Poster to Encourage North Vietnamese to move South
This poster was produced by the Americans and South Vietnamese to convince the Catholics and non-Communists in the north to head south. It depicts murder and violence above the 17th Parallel and peace and happiness below. The poster is entitled Come south. The text at the top is:
Go to the South to avoid Communism
Text at the bottom of the poster is:
Your South Vietnamese compatriots are waiting to welcome their North Vietnamese compatriots with open arms.
Lansdale was then sent to Saigon by the Central Intelligence Agency to gather intelligence on the Communists and do everything possible to disrupt Ho Chi Minh's organization of the populace of North Vietnam. Lansdale was never a CIA employee, For the Manila assignment, he had been detailed to the Agency from the Air Force; this arrangement was now extended for his service in
. Secretary of State John Foster Dulles and his brother Allen, the Director of Central Intelligence, directly participated in creating the assignment. Their participation resulted in Lansdale's being sent out as chief of a second Station, reporting neither to McCarthy in Saigon nor to the chief of the Far East Division, but directly to Allen Dulles. Tran Do Cam adds: Vietnam
Colonel Lansdale's organization in
Vietnamwas called the Saigon Military Mission (Phái Bô Quân Sú Saigon) and it included Infantry Major Lucien Conein, a professional spy who would play a very important role in the political upheavals that characterized the First Republicin . South Vietnam
Just before the North was handed over to the Communists, many Vietnamese civilians were recruited by Colonel Lansdale. Most of them came from the Vietnamese ethnic minority known as the Nùng and some were native to Móng Cái, which is near Hâi Phòng. Others came from areas near the Chinese-Vietnam border, however, they were all sent to
Saipanfor training in the basics of counterinsurgency.
Lansdale organized rumor campaigns in Hanoi threatening Chinese rule under Ho, and claiming that Chinese soldiers were raping Vietnamese women. He printed fake Viet Minh leaflets which were disseminated in the North and threatened property confiscation, monetary changes and harsh treatment of workers under the Communist regime. He started rumors that "Christ has gone to the South" and "the Virgin Mary has departed from the North." He hinted that the United States would drop atom bombs on the North, a story that was further promoted by leaflets showing concentric circles of destruction of the city by an atomic bomb. He produced leaflets that implied that Vietnamese would be sent into China to work as railroad laborers. Whatever he did, nearly one million North Vietnamese fled southward, many of them Catholics. He contaminated the oil supply of the Hanoi bus company and buried arms to be used by partisans when the uprising against the Communists occurred. Of course, the uprising never happened. This master of black operations is the consultant tasked to advise Barry Zorthian, whom we might consider an "innocent" civilian. What a pair they must have made.
Lt. Tom Dooley, a young Irish Catholic Navy doctor, was loaned by the US Navy to Lansdale for the operation. Dooley functioned as the teams propagandist, visiting news media and sending out reports through Catholic media in the United States that supported the CIAs anti-Viet Minh mission. The Navy gave Dooley a leave of absence to write a book titled Deliver us from Evil, about his experiences with North Vietnamese refugees who wanted to move to the South.
Roberts mentions Lansdale in Let the Dogs Bark: The Psychological War in Vietnam, 1960-1968:
Lansdale hired a Vietnamese counterfeiter to produce a bogus Viet Minh leaflet instructing citizens of the north on how to behave when the Communists took over; the leaflet told them to make a tally of their possessions so that the Viet Minh would know what to confiscate. This black PSYOP was so successful that it even fooled Viet Minh officials.
Operation Passage to Freedom, as the migration program was known, resulted in most of the northern Catholic population fleeing to South Vietnam. Under Lansdales guidance, the Americans expanded psychological warfare training in the South Vietnamese Army. The hasty instruction program taught soldiers how to enter a village and greet civilians in a respectful manner. Lansdale urged Diem to act more like a campaigning American politician, visiting the countryside, meeting the people, and providing greater visibility. However, Diem remained reluctant to become the glad-handing politico, perhaps for valid cultural reasons. In the first half of 1963, American advisers observed dramatic improvements in governance and the skill of the Strategic Hamlet program militia in repelling the Viet Cong.
Lansdale tried to work with the French and apparently learned a lot from them. Unfortunately, there was a constant fight over who would have the most influence over this new Vietnam. Some of that story is told in: French and American Intelligence Relations During the First Indochina War, 195054: Jean-Marc LePage, PhD, and Elie Tenenbaum. The authors say in part:
As the French were retreating from Indochina in mid-1954, US intelligence returned to counter-guerrilla issues as it realized it would have to carry the burden of preventing a communist takeover of Southeast Asia after the French departure. During this period, there is no doubt about Col. Edward G. Lansdales involvement in French-American collaboration as head of the so-called Saigon Military Mission (SMM), a covert group entirely separate from the regular CIA station. The SMM fit in the framework of the Military Assistance Advisory Group. For a time the SMM was under the cover of the Training Relations and Instruction Mission (TRIM). According to Lansdale, who seemed very enthusiastic about it in the beginning, the TRIM was a French-American institution that aimed to push French and Americans to work together to help the Vietnamese to take the control of their own affairs. The official US Army history of the period describes it as a joint training institution intended to improve the ability of the Vietnamese military to stand up to communist attacks. The mission only lasted until April 1956, when the French withdrew the remainder of their expeditionary force from the country.
Within the TRIM was the National Security Division, which was in fact another name for pacification and counterinsurgency operations. The mission allowed Lansdale to learn French know-how in counterinsurgency, in the form of the Mobile Administrative Groups from which he derived a new kind of unit: the Civic Action Teams, which were supposed to go out in the countryside and work in the villages to foster self-rule, self-development and self-defense. This kind of activity, resembling the usual practice of the Viet Minh peasant-soldiers, will be found again in the Revolutionary Development set up by Tom Donohue in 1964, then in the Civil Operations and Revolutionary Development Support (CORDS) after 1967.
John R, Campbell, a civilian psychological warfare advisor in
Vietnamfrom 1965 to 1967 makes an interesting point about Lansdalein Are we Winning? Are they Winning: A Civilian Advisors Reflections on Wartime , Author House, 2004. He seems to think that it was just as important to talk the anti-communist indigenous people of Vietnam to head south as the Catholics: Vietnam
One of the wars interesting what ifs could have been what if U.S. Colonel (later General) Edward Lansdales eminently successful operations to stimulate and facilitate the movement of the Catholics of
North Vietnamto the South during s partition in 1954 had been replicated with the estimated million strong Nung population in the North. These fierce and efficient anti-Communist fighters, who had served the French so well against the Viet Minh, could have added the equivalent of several divisions to the Souths sorely needy defense. Those relatively few, who apparently succeeded in making the trek on their own initiative, were eventually greatly appreciated well beyond their numbers. Vietnam
Neil Sheehan says in A Bright and Shining Lie that
, it can be truly said, was the creation of Edward Lansdale. South Vietnam
Don Rochlen October 1965
Donald H. Rochlen is an interesting character. If Lansdale was the early American PSYOP expert, Rochlen seems to be expert near the end of the war. He started off in 1955 in Thailand as a U.S. Embassy Press Officer and later an attaché and the liaison between the embassy and the United States Information Agency with the USIA title of Educational Exchange Officer.
Don Rochlen explains the American 1956 Presidential Election system to studentswhile in Thailand. General Dwight D. Eisenhower is victorious with 41 states. The discussion was broadcast on a television channel for young people sponsored by the Thai Deputy Prime Minister General Thanom Kittitikachorn.
After some language training he became a Cultural Exchange Officer in Bangkok for three years (until 1961). He was then assigned to the Voice of America broadcasting in Thai and Lao until about 1965. He next went to Saigon where he served from 1965 to 1971. At first, he was on temporary duty (TDY) to supervise the production of Vietnamese-language radio programs to be broadcast on the Voice of America. He was later assigned as a special projects officer interviewing farmers, Vietnamese soldiers, Viet Cong members and North Vietnamese defectors and researching facts to be used in Vietnamese-American psychological operations. He advanced to the position of Chief of Special Projects for the Field Development Division of JUSPAO. His assignment was to generate PSYWAR ideas and to develop loudspeaker programs, posters and leaflets. He worked extensively with Viet Cong defectors and prisoners and placed what he learned into leaflets and radio broadcasts.
On 3 April 1968 he received a medal from the Chieu Hoi Ministry. He was asked by the Ministry to write one biographical paragraph which would be placed on the certificate. It was felt that he knew better than anyone what he had done for the Chieu Hoi operation.
Don Rochlen takes part in Operation El Paso II which was launched in Binh Long province on 2 June and ended 13 July 1968. Sitting at the right is his North Vietnamese interpreter and radio man Nguyen Van Quy. We assume Rochlen is waiting for POWs to interrogate.
He left briefly, and then was called back in the summer of 1972 attached to the United States Information Service to interview Vietnamese citizens living in areas heavily attacked by the Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese Army. He prepared four unclassified reports for the United States Information Service and then returned to Thailand in late 1972 where he was assigned as the Psychological Operations Advisor with the Southeast Asia Treaty Organization. In this position he made occasional trips to Vietnam.
Rochlen was a trouble-shooter. Like Lansdale, he got the tough jobs. He seems to have worked, possibly as a PSYOP advisor with Lieutenant General Tran Van Trung, the head of the South Vietnamese Political Warfare Department and Major General Nguyen Van Binh of the National Police. Like Lansdale, he often worked with the Central Intelligence Agency, but never for them.
He was important enough for the Hanoi newspaper Quan Doi Nhan Dan (The Peoples Army Newspaper) to attack him in print. The newspaper claimed that when the Republic of Vietnam was in full retreat in 1975, he developed a rumor campaign to terrify the southerners and motivate their army to fight on. Some of his alleged rumors were that with a Communist victory there would be a blood bath. Well-coiffured heads would be shaved and spread with lime. Fingernails and toenails that wore decadent polish would be torn out by pliers. Collective graves would be dug for hundreds of thousands of people. Long six-inch iron nails would be hammered into the heads of people who had collaborated with the Americans. Buddhists would be immolated. Catholics would be forced into churches and dynamited. Other religious people would be thrown into the rivers to drown. He concluded that the Communists would kill 10 regular troops for every one they spared and the police would all be killed and their skin used to make shoes.
Rochlen later debunked the article in depth. He was not in Vietnam and in no position to pass rumors in 1975.
An American who worked with Rochlen said:
He was a legendary figure in Vietnam -- on an equal in the eyes of many veterans with John Paul Vann and Bill Colby.
About a decade after I wrote this article, I heard from one of Don Rochlens aides in Vietnam during 1970 and 1971. Captain Robert Turner was the Assistant Special Projects Officer in the North Vietnam Army/Viet Cong Division at the Joint U.S. Public Affairs Office. He told me:
Don Rochlen was in Saigon briefly in April 1975. He was not assigned there, but he returned on his own to try to help people who he knew were in special danger because of their work with us to get out during the evacuation. I was with him in the office of a mutual friend in the Embassy when the U.S. Ambassador to Thailand called and yelled at Don to get his butt back to Bangkok. Don responded that the connection was not good, the Ambassador was breaking up, and please say ag and hung up the phone. He then went about doing the good he had come to do.
Many of us who had studied Vietnamese Communism warned that a Communist victory would lead to a bloodbath, not as a disinformation propaganda campaign but because we knew it to be true. I left Vietnam and the Army at the end of 1971 and became a Fellow at Stanfords Hoover Institution, where I wrote the first major history of Vietnamese Communism in English and published several articles warning of a bloodbath.
I am not familiar with everything Don did in 1975 (by then I had left the Army). I stumbled across Don in Saigon and during the final days of April 1975 we both slept on the floor of a mutual friends apartment in Saigonbut I would be surprised if he was involved in a disinformation program as claimed by the Communists. We knew that Hanoi and the Viet Cong were aware of our office and were not fond of us (especially of Don, who had been there for years and was very effective), but anything Don did to warn of a bloodbath came from the heart. And the reality of what happened after liberation certainly persuaded me that a bloodbath had occurredwith millions of dead throughout Indochina.
In a New York Times story dated 15 October 1972, Robert Turner mentioned the land reform program in North Vietnam after the Viet Minh victory in 1954 as an example of what could happen after a Communist victory in South Vietnam and said:
Whether the actual bloodbath was 300,000 or 500,000 it is quite clear that a major purge did occur and that the casualties numbered in six digits.
On 15 April 1992, Charles Stuart Kennedy interviewed William Lloyd Stearman for the Association for Diplomatic Studies. Stearman was a critic of JUSPAO and how they did things, but he was a fan of Rochlen. He said:
There were, however, some good people in JUSPAO. Take a chap by the name of Don Rochlen, for example. He would have been out of place in most normal organizations, but he had a real genius for psychological operations, somewhat eccentric, but extremely effective. There were some characters like that who were very good, but most of them, I am afraid, took more of a bureaucratic view of things. It wasn't the program it could have and should have been.
The War Ends
There really is no way to write a conclusion to this article because the war lasted too long and there are too many differing attitudes and opinions. There were programs that worked and programs that didnt work and they will all be forever argued. What did the Communists think of it all? After they took power, how did they react to the thousands of leaflets, books, posters, radio broadcasts, motion pictures and the like that had been prepared by the American Government and the Government of Vietnam?
Vietnam researcher and University of California (Berkeley) Library Assistant Steve Denney quotes various North Vietnamese leaders and newspapers that show that the Communists were frightened by the propaganda and considered it very dangerous. Some of his comments are:
On the first day of
's liberation, May 1, 1975, the Military Management Committee issued a communiqué ordering the temporary suspension of all kinds of books, newspapers, magazines and other printed material owned during the period. In Saigon, in one district only, within less than a week, the people turned in 482,460 copies of depraved literature and 3,000 kilos of reactionary newspapers formerly published by the enemy. One bookstore in Nha Trang surrendered 35,530 "reactionary books." South Vietnam HanoiLiberation Radio said in a broadcast on June 30, 1975 that the people in the district town of province "turned over to the revolutionary administration more than 3,000 novels and song books and hundreds of records and tapes which were reactionary in content and poisonous to the youth." Bac Lieu
Speaking at a May Day meeting in Ho Chi Minh City, Vo Van Kiet, a high-ranking Communist official, complained of youth songs, which through spontaneous development, have been made by a number of elements to resemble the youth music of the puppet regime and cater to the extremely egotistic tastes of remnants of the old society who are trying to rear their heads. They entice listeners to shirk obligations, detach themselves from reality, turn their backs on our people's life of labor and combat, regret the past and idolize imperialism.
So, although it sometimes seemed that American military commanders were not sold on propaganda, the Communists were. Clearly, the first thing they did upon taking power was to send out teams to pick up every piece of printed material, song or motion picture that was sympathetic to the old regime. They had no doubt that American propaganda was poison to their cause.
This article started out as a short commemoration to honor the psychological operations units that served in
. It had grown by leaps and bounds and any reader with comments, additions, or suggestions is encouraged to send them to the author at firstname.lastname@example.org. Vietnam
© End: 18 January 2006